Motor Testing and Comparisons
#676
A little fill in from testing. Yes the nes motors have lower IR readings and do show a bit more power. But the removal of the heat sinking compounds have caused gearing and timing changes that take back some of that power. This only applies to the 10.5 thru 21.5 motors the 25.5 just jumped from around 30 watts to 40 watts (at a 5v test). So once you get them right, they aren't much if any faster. I ran quicker with a G4R HT epoxy than a new G5 HT in WGTR. Simply because of heat control.
Yes, I have seen a difference in heat. Especially with the R1. I guess it would also depend on the type of racing. In offroad, too much timing or gearing will take out too much torque, so jumping and accelerating out of corners became a problem. I have seen most racers gear back down to regain torque. In these instances, the new motors were taking the lead.
#677
I've also done some back to back testing of my G4R 13.5T against a G5, and lap times were the same.
I'm not convinced there's a big generational gap.
#678
Joined: Aug 2008
Posts: 2,388
From: Medina, Ohio
Yes, I have seen a difference in heat. Especially with the R1. I guess it would also depend on the type of racing. In offroad, too much timing or gearing will take out too much torque, so jumping and accelerating out of corners became a problem. I have seen most racers gear back down to regain torque. In these instances, the new motors were taking the lead.
#679
Were the temps the same, as well as the torque? Interesting. I have not tested the G5 yet. I've heard mixed feelings on it. I believe it has a narrower stator to bring up the RPM. The VR30R was not impressive. Feel it has a little more power, but it gets way too hot. I would really like to get another one and do a thorough test on timing points.
On another note, I should be getting the new Zombie in this week. It's coming from China, so...
#680
Were the temps the same, as well as the torque? Interesting. I have not tested the G5 yet. I've heard mixed feelings on it. I believe it has a narrower stator to bring up the RPM. The VR30R was not impressive. Feel it has a little more power, but it gets way too hot. I would really like to get another one and do a thorough test on timing points.
On another note, I should be getting the new Zombie in this week. It's coming from China, so...
On another note, I should be getting the new Zombie in this week. It's coming from China, so...
I'm pretty sure the stator is the same size, legally they can't make it any shorter. It's just mounted deeper in the can.
#681
Still running a Tekin out at Auburn RC in 13.5 wheeler and am doing quite well with it. Its the Epoxy version and it legal until the end of the year so I will run it all summer and be better with the heat. I’ve already figured out heat and gearing for multiple new motors for on road asphalt and carpet. Outdoor off road hasn’t had track temperatures as high as asphalt has as of yet but I’ll be prepared for it if it does. Track temps last week hit 125 on the dirt. Getting there but not yet.
#682
Were the temps the same, as well as the torque? Interesting. I have not tested the G5 yet. I've heard mixed feelings on it. I believe it has a narrower stator to bring up the RPM. The VR30R was not impressive. Feel it has a little more power, but it gets way too hot. I would really like to get another one and do a thorough test on timing points.
On another note, I should be getting the new Zombie in this week. It's coming from China, so...
On another note, I should be getting the new Zombie in this week. It's coming from China, so...
#683
Didn't pay too much attention to the temperature, it's cool weather over here and my temp gun has failed. Both felt like they were in the same range with the "does it burn my finger?" test. I didn't notice any difference in torque, but I'd need a dyno for that.
I'm pretty sure the stator is the same size, legally they can't make it any shorter. It's just mounted deeper in the can.
I'm pretty sure the stator is the same size, legally they can't make it any shorter. It's just mounted deeper in the can.
Not the length. I believe the diameter is smaller. I'm still waiting to get on my bench, but I'm told it is skinnier.
#685
#686
#687
It would be weird for a prototype to have a different diameter, since the diameter is controlled pretty tight by the ROAR specs. Are you sure it wasn't an outlaw motor he was looking at?
#688
I was told it like the SpeedZone motor. It looks like a fat stator, but it's a standard diameter stator with smaller diameter endbells to match the diameter of the stator.
Are you going to be at the Racers Den tomorrow (Friday) night? I'm going to try and stop by. My son might even bring his buggy to race it.



533Likes
