Official Tekin RX8 GEN2 ESC Thread
#3226
I agree with Platgof. I currently have 3 rx8 esc's and they been super reliable. The first one I got, I bought it in mid 2014 for my 4wd sct and I can tell you that its been tru hell. I burned motors(testing), puffed batteries, even plugged it wrong(reverse polarity) for like half a second and did not burned. I also own an rxs, an rs spec and a rs gen2. Great ESC's. I don't really like the 1/10 scale motors tho. seem to be weak. My trackstar 7.5Tv2 has more cojones than the tekin gen2 7.5T. Just my opinion.
#3228
That is a picture of an old Gen1 unit, interesting to post that one. 1/8 On-road is a different monster all together. The load being placed on the entire system and parts involved is pretty impressive overall. We've been working with the Serpent factory on setups an they've been quite happy and very reliable.
When looking at data logs from racers we often find the batteries being used are simply not sufficient for the load the system is asking for. 1/8 on-road isn't going to work with 30c batteries and cheap connectors.
Care must be taken when choosing components for this genre of racing. It's a much higher load than 1/8 Off-road simply due to he grip the cars generate.
The most successful setup has been 6s and a 1900kv in most conditions. Where we see the most issues is classes/racers regulated to 4s. This forces guys to use 2650's(one of the nastiest loads around) and 4s batteries. These MUST be up to the task of supplying the esc with the power it needs to drive the motor. We see big power spikes and blown caps when cheaper and or less quality batteries being used in these conditions.
When looking at data logs from racers we often find the batteries being used are simply not sufficient for the load the system is asking for. 1/8 on-road isn't going to work with 30c batteries and cheap connectors.
Care must be taken when choosing components for this genre of racing. It's a much higher load than 1/8 Off-road simply due to he grip the cars generate.
The most successful setup has been 6s and a 1900kv in most conditions. Where we see the most issues is classes/racers regulated to 4s. This forces guys to use 2650's(one of the nastiest loads around) and 4s batteries. These MUST be up to the task of supplying the esc with the power it needs to drive the motor. We see big power spikes and blown caps when cheaper and or less quality batteries being used in these conditions.
I find it interesting that you repeatedly like to point the finger at things like batteries etc, when a Trackstar 150A (rated LESS than an RX8) which costs a third the price, has three times the warranty, handles our GT "Nasty loads" just fine. I have seen more than one RX8 / RX8 Gen 2 fail at on road, as well as numerous IX8's, most people now run the Trackstar 150 or Xerun 150 as they have been the most reliable.
This finger pointing reminds me of Castle when their ESC's first started becoming unexplained fireballs (ie MMM and MMM V2, MMMXL, MMMXL V2 before they went to XL2) and it's disappointing.
Credit where it's due, the RS / RS Pro / RSX have been fine, the RX8 is fine in a 4wd SCT application, but in an application like 1/8 On Road which on paper should be fine, it fails, and fails badly. Most of us who race this class are very conscious of batteries, Internal Resistance is what I use, as soon as a packs resting IR is over 10moh a cell, it's out of there, your "Max Amps are often 5moh new, Trackstar Nanotech Ultimates are often under 3.
At the end of the day most people will judge a company on how they deal with issues regarding their products, do they look for something to blame or do they look after the consumer?
#3229
Tech Apprentice
iTrader: (2)
Joined: Oct 2014
Posts: 75
From: Medina, OH
I am having trouble with my RX8 gen 2. I stopped my 1/8 buggy on the track to check my transmitter settings. When I pulled the trigger to go again---nothing. No lights, no tones or fan. I thought it was the old power switch so I shorted it out, no luck. If I hook up Hotwire to the fan connector I can link with hotwire. Otherwise the ESC is dead.
I cannot get the ESC to respond when I hook up to the receiver lead. Is that normal?
Anyone have any ideas?
I cannot get the ESC to respond when I hook up to the receiver lead. Is that normal?
Anyone have any ideas?
#3230
I am having trouble with my RX8 gen 2. I stopped my 1/8 buggy on the track to check my transmitter settings. When I pulled the trigger to go again---nothing. No lights, no tones or fan. I thought it was the old power switch so I shorted it out, no luck. If I hook up Hotwire to the fan connector I can link with hotwire. Otherwise the ESC is dead.
I cannot get the ESC to respond when I hook up to the receiver lead. Is that normal?
Anyone have any ideas?
I cannot get the ESC to respond when I hook up to the receiver lead. Is that normal?
Anyone have any ideas?
Seriously though try a different battery or plug it could be as simple as a cold solder joint
#3231
Tech Apprentice
iTrader: (2)
Joined: Oct 2014
Posts: 75
From: Medina, OH
I tried a couple different batteries.
I checked that there is voltage (15.6 VDC) at the ESC.
Do you know if the receiver lead on the ESC can be used to connect to Hotwire? It doesn't work on my ESC so I am thinking maybe a wire got pinched between the ESC and receiver. Not sure if that would cause this kind of symptom though
I checked that there is voltage (15.6 VDC) at the ESC.
Do you know if the receiver lead on the ESC can be used to connect to Hotwire? It doesn't work on my ESC so I am thinking maybe a wire got pinched between the ESC and receiver. Not sure if that would cause this kind of symptom though
#3233
I tried a couple different batteries.
I checked that there is voltage (15.6 VDC) at the ESC.
Do you know if the receiver lead on the ESC can be used to connect to Hotwire? It doesn't work on my ESC so I am thinking maybe a wire got pinched between the ESC and receiver. Not sure if that would cause this kind of symptom though
I checked that there is voltage (15.6 VDC) at the ESC.
Do you know if the receiver lead on the ESC can be used to connect to Hotwire? It doesn't work on my ESC so I am thinking maybe a wire got pinched between the ESC and receiver. Not sure if that would cause this kind of symptom though
1) You should be able to connect both from the fan and from the rx cable.
2) If you have power to the ESC it should go into the arming mode when it first gets that power (assuming switch is on or shorted as you mentioned).
3) A short in the control wire could cause it to not arm, as it won't arm until it senses neutral.
4) This all happened after you changed settings on your radio.
Some questions:
1) What setting(s) did you change on the radio?
2) Did you slow to a stop, or crash to a stop, when you decided to change settings?
3) Does your rx light up and get power while this is happening?
4) Can you turn the wheels with the steering servo while a battery is powering everything?
Since you can connect the hotwire, tell the hotwire to update the firmware on the ESC. This will wipe everything in there and reset to factory everything in case something somehow got corrupted or one of your settings is no longer the setting you need (for example, if neutral width is now smaller than your radio system needs).
#3234
Tech Apprentice
iTrader: (2)
Joined: Oct 2014
Posts: 75
From: Medina, OH
Justpoet,
Thanks for the reply. The ESC doesn't not start the arming process. There is no sign of life. That is why I first thought it was the power switch.
I opened up the case and the wires all look fine, and I could not see any damage at all.
1. I was only starting the count down timer on the radio. Not much of a change.
2. just coasted to a stop so I could simulate a 4 min qualifier. I had only done 2 warm up laps so It was not overheating.
3. & 4.No output from the BEC.
I did an update to V 254 from 250 and it said that the update was successful.
The only thing I noted was that the fan connector can be used to link with Hotwire but the receiver connector will not.
Thanks for the reply. The ESC doesn't not start the arming process. There is no sign of life. That is why I first thought it was the power switch.
I opened up the case and the wires all look fine, and I could not see any damage at all.
1. I was only starting the count down timer on the radio. Not much of a change.
2. just coasted to a stop so I could simulate a 4 min qualifier. I had only done 2 warm up laps so It was not overheating.
3. & 4.No output from the BEC.
I did an update to V 254 from 250 and it said that the update was successful.
The only thing I noted was that the fan connector can be used to link with Hotwire but the receiver connector will not.
#3236
Tech Apprentice
iTrader: (2)
Joined: Oct 2014
Posts: 75
From: Medina, OH
I did a continuity check on the receiver lead and that is OK. Looks like there is no simple fix. I am not sure if I should send this in to get repaired or just buy a new Monster X. The X has a lot of usable features like all the leads come out the top, the servo, power switch and fan are on a harness so it is easy to repair a pinched lead, sensored/non-sensored control, 6.5 mm bullet connectors to the motor, aux channel that can be used for anything but I like to use it for enabling/disabling reverse for practice/racing ...
I wish Tekin would make this decision easier by adding some value to their side of the equation.
I wish Tekin would make this decision easier by adding some value to their side of the equation.
#3237
I did a continuity check on the receiver lead and that is OK. Looks like there is no simple fix. I am not sure if I should send this in to get repaired or just buy a new Monster X. The X has a lot of usable features like all the leads come out the top, the servo, power switch and fan are on a harness so it is easy to repair a pinched lead, sensored/non-sensored control, 6.5 mm bullet connectors to the motor, aux channel that can be used for anything but I like to use it for enabling/disabling reverse for practice/racing ...
I wish Tekin would make this decision easier by adding some value to their side of the equation.
I wish Tekin would make this decision easier by adding some value to their side of the equation.
#3240
I find it interesting that you repeatedly like to point the finger at things like batteries etc, when a Trackstar 150A (rated LESS than an RX8) which costs a third the price, has three times the warranty, handles our GT "Nasty loads" just fine. I have seen more than one RX8 / RX8 Gen 2 fail at on road, as well as numerous IX8's, most people now run the Trackstar 150 or Xerun 150 as they have been the most reliable.
This finger pointing reminds me of Castle when their ESC's first started becoming unexplained fireballs (ie MMM and MMM V2, MMMXL, MMMXL V2 before they went to XL2) and it's disappointing.
Credit where it's due, the RS / RS Pro / RSX have been fine, the RX8 is fine in a 4wd SCT application, but in an application like 1/8 On Road which on paper should be fine, it fails, and fails badly. Most of us who race this class are very conscious of batteries, Internal Resistance is what I use, as soon as a packs resting IR is over 10moh a cell, it's out of there, your "Max Amps are often 5moh new, Trackstar Nanotech Ultimates are often under 3.
At the end of the day most people will judge a company on how they deal with issues regarding their products, do they look for something to blame or do they look after the consumer?
This finger pointing reminds me of Castle when their ESC's first started becoming unexplained fireballs (ie MMM and MMM V2, MMMXL, MMMXL V2 before they went to XL2) and it's disappointing.
Credit where it's due, the RS / RS Pro / RSX have been fine, the RX8 is fine in a 4wd SCT application, but in an application like 1/8 On Road which on paper should be fine, it fails, and fails badly. Most of us who race this class are very conscious of batteries, Internal Resistance is what I use, as soon as a packs resting IR is over 10moh a cell, it's out of there, your "Max Amps are often 5moh new, Trackstar Nanotech Ultimates are often under 3.
At the end of the day most people will judge a company on how they deal with issues regarding their products, do they look for something to blame or do they look after the consumer?
While internal resistance can be a factor, the ability of the pack to deliver the power is what we're looking at.
Send me a data log, let's take a look at your setup and see what's going on.



20Likes