Tamiya mini cooper
Can ESC's make our silvercans faster?
Wondering if my Traxxas esc isn't delivering enough battery to the motor? or, phrased different, if other guys using a different ESC have an advantage w/ higher burst rates?? My Traxxas says it delivers a constant 100A of power, whereas a LRP or Novak may have a constant of 70A but a burst of 370A (my traxxas doesn't specify what the burst rates are -if any)?
Would this play a factor???
Wondering if my Traxxas esc isn't delivering enough battery to the motor? or, phrased different, if other guys using a different ESC have an advantage w/ higher burst rates?? My Traxxas says it delivers a constant 100A of power, whereas a LRP or Novak may have a constant of 70A but a burst of 370A (my traxxas doesn't specify what the burst rates are -if any)?
Would this play a factor???
No. Don't worry about the ESC. Just make sure that you have calibrated everything so you are getting 100% throttle when you pull the trigger all the way.
going to focus on the motor.
geesh,
this variance in slivercans is driving me a bit nuts.
I absolutely do not want to cheat, but is also sucks racing against guys who obviously have faster motors. Well, it's all about fun ...I am enjoying it so that is all that matters.
I do have a few silvercans at home, I may do some comparrisons to see if some are faster than others?
Can ESC's make our silvercans faster?
Wondering if my Traxxas esc isn't delivering enough battery to the motor? or, phrased different, if other guys using a different ESC have an advantage w/ higher burst rates?? My Traxxas says it delivers a constant 100A of power, whereas a LRP or Novak may have a constant of 70A but a burst of 370A (my traxxas doesn't specify what the burst rates are -if any)?
Would this play a factor???
this variance in slivercans is driving me a bit nuts.
I absolutely do not want to cheat, but is also sucks racing against guys who obviously have faster motors. Well, it's all about fun ...I am enjoying it so that is all that matters.
I do have a few silvercans at home, I may do some comparrisons to see if some are faster than others?
Can ESC's make our silvercans faster?
Wondering if my Traxxas esc isn't delivering enough battery to the motor? or, phrased different, if other guys using a different ESC have an advantage w/ higher burst rates?? My Traxxas says it delivers a constant 100A of power, whereas a LRP or Novak may have a constant of 70A but a burst of 370A (my traxxas doesn't specify what the burst rates are -if any)?
Would this play a factor???
EDIT: The Slash ESC PWM frequency is 1.7kHz.
-Thanks Carl,
...yeah, since I have a few extra Silvercans laying around I am going to start there. -just see if what I have makes a difference (over the kit motor).
After that if no difference then i'll check out the ESC route and your suggestions. I'll let you know what I find (stay tuned)! -I may have an extra LRP esc, -just have to check if it is a quantum 3 (that sounds familiar though)
...yeah, since I have a few extra Silvercans laying around I am going to start there. -just see if what I have makes a difference (over the kit motor).
After that if no difference then i'll check out the ESC route and your suggestions. I'll let you know what I find (stay tuned)! -I may have an extra LRP esc, -just have to check if it is a quantum 3 (that sounds familiar though)
So long as you replace the diff putty every 3-4 full race sessions you're good. The only time the diff putty leaks out of there is too much diff movement, hence the reason I add an additional diff shim. The putty I'm referring to is thick enough you can roll into small balls. The instructions show rolling into 3x 10mm balls and placing it between the planetary gears. I did this the first time around the diff came too loose after a few runs. I now pack the entire diff, just enough so there is little diff action. Helps to pull the car around the corners. Not sure what blu-tac is? Its almost full lock, but there is some diff action with some efforts
Trying to decide where to go with the M05 diff. Think I'll run the 3Racing with some heavy silicone and see where it goes. May look at the putty option later, depending on how stable the car is.
Thanks, Carl. All things considered, I'll probably stick with the stock diff and extra shims (3 per side) in my M03. It's reliable for 6 months at a stretch of racing twice a week. Even then it doesn't really need more than a cleaning. Besides, I'm finally going to focus on a single car this season and that's the 05 v2.
Trying to decide where to go with the M05 diff. Think I'll run the 3Racing with some heavy silicone and see where it goes. May look at the putty option later, depending on how stable the car is.
Trying to decide where to go with the M05 diff. Think I'll run the 3Racing with some heavy silicone and see where it goes. May look at the putty option later, depending on how stable the car is.
No. Too LOW a frequency will wear the comm faster, since the inductance of the motor won't smooth out the current for low fequencies. Almost any brushed ESC made in the last decade has an output frequency high enough to avoid this on a silvercan.
EDIT: The Slash ESC PWM frequency is 1.7kHz.
EDIT: The Slash ESC PWM frequency is 1.7kHz.
No, not 3 per side, two on one side and a single shim on the other, so three in total. I try a fourth shim (two and two) and it too tight plus the plastic side doesn't close down all the way without being warped. If the gearing is too tight, you may have to run the gears in a drill with some polish. Build the diff and put on side of the out drive in a cordless drill and spin at a slow speed while holding the gear. Once completed clean out the gears an pack with diff putty.
Tech Elite

Joined: Oct 2006
Posts: 2,367
Interesting stuff on "pitting" the comm. I've been very lucky to have never seen it. This is on a "stock" Silvercan. It could happen if the motor was abused for long periods of time. The drive frequency is moot from a practical standpoint as related to motor wear. Besides, buying a $160 KO, with a card and plugging it into your computer to adjust it ------?????? With that being said, that's what's in my cars, but for being able to adjust the drivability rather than anything else. The LRP Q3 is a good esc, but the Tekin is as good. The main problem with the LRP is that it's no longer available and can't be serviced. Also the cases had a tendency to come apart.
For comparison testing, using old motors complicates things quite a bit. There are different production "runs" of these motors and they vary. Some had hard brushes and others had a much softer brush. The current ones have a CS initialed on the brushes. These seem to be the most consistent and IMO the quickest in stock form. Also, the amount of brush wear can give you misleading info. Another factor is whether the motor was overheated or abused in any way.
You'll hear of many "old school" tricks to make these motors go faster, but most don't amount to much. Some even lead to more problems. Among these are breaking in the bushings, centering the comm to the magnets, etc. Fun to "play" with tho.
For comparison testing, using old motors complicates things quite a bit. There are different production "runs" of these motors and they vary. Some had hard brushes and others had a much softer brush. The current ones have a CS initialed on the brushes. These seem to be the most consistent and IMO the quickest in stock form. Also, the amount of brush wear can give you misleading info. Another factor is whether the motor was overheated or abused in any way.
You'll hear of many "old school" tricks to make these motors go faster, but most don't amount to much. Some even lead to more problems. Among these are breaking in the bushings, centering the comm to the magnets, etc. Fun to "play" with tho.



295Likes