Servo Failure
#1
I am currently running a futaba B451 in my sc10 4x4. Twice now I have had to replace the nylon gear in it. All the other gears are metal. The problem is you can't just buy the nylon gear you have to buy the whole set. At $36 a pop. Obviously each time it broke I hit a tube or had a hard landing but that was never a problem when I ran this servo in my SCTE. I am looing to try a Savox servo can someone recomend one that will survive in this truck? How much torque do I need in a servo for it to last.
#5
Tech Master
iTrader: (39)
Joined: Oct 2011
Posts: 1,293
From: Henderson, NV
I am currently running a futaba B451 in my sc10 4x4. Twice now I have had to replace the nylon gear in it. All the other gears are metal. The problem is you can't just buy the nylon gear you have to buy the whole set. At $36 a pop. Obviously each time it broke I hit a tube or had a hard landing but that was never a problem when I ran this servo in my SCTE. I am looing to try a Savox servo can someone recomend one that will survive in this truck? How much torque do I need in a servo for it to last.
#7
I always ran my SCTE servo saver tight and thought I could with this truck as well but I believe your right the servo saver needs to be looser on this truck. I had my hobby shop telling me that I needed a servo with more torque. Thanks for the replies
#10
I love Futaba servos. But I think thats a poor choice for that truck. I think a good one for that truck would be the ace/ds1015. For 4wd SC I'd be looking for >180 tq and <.10 speed. With the higher torque servos you normally get all metal gears because if they didn't put them in they would fail for sure. I don't personally care for Savox but a lot of people use them with out any issues. I'd look at the Savox 1258TG.
So in a way I agree with your local hobby shop. And just think, if it fails again you could have bought a brand new servo that is better suited to that truck for what you have spent fixing it.
#11
If it is $36 each time you have to repair it, I would run it until it failed again and then simply take a moment to consider replacing the whole servo vs repairing it.
Just adds up too fast if it keeps breaking, worth buying your way out of that problem at some point.
Just adds up too fast if it keeps breaking, worth buying your way out of that problem at some point.
#12
SCTE servo savor =/= SC10 4x4 servo saver. All of them are different and need to be adjusted accordingly.
I love Futaba servos. But I think thats a poor choice for that truck. I think a good one for that truck would be the ace/ds1015. For 4wd SC I'd be looking for >180 tq and <.10 speed. With the higher torque servos you normally get all metal gears because if they didn't put them in they would fail for sure. I don't personally care for Savox but a lot of people use them with out any issues. I'd look at the Savox 1258TG.
So in a way I agree with your local hobby shop. And just think, if it fails again you could have bought a brand new servo that is better suited to that truck for what you have spent fixing it.
I love Futaba servos. But I think thats a poor choice for that truck. I think a good one for that truck would be the ace/ds1015. For 4wd SC I'd be looking for >180 tq and <.10 speed. With the higher torque servos you normally get all metal gears because if they didn't put them in they would fail for sure. I don't personally care for Savox but a lot of people use them with out any issues. I'd look at the Savox 1258TG.
So in a way I agree with your local hobby shop. And just think, if it fails again you could have bought a brand new servo that is better suited to that truck for what you have spent fixing it.

#13
Suspended
iTrader: (3)
Joined: Nov 2008
Posts: 326
Yes to all metal gears ..Hitec MG 900 series I run a MG 945 in one of my scte..also a MG985..My son who is alot more crash happy runs a BlueBird HS MG 626 fast and all metal can get them New for $30.. I bought a box of Hitecs along time ago for 100$ there was 12 used 900 servos in it..
#14
Yes to all metal gears ..Hitec MG 900 series I run a MG 945 in one of my scte..also a MG985..My son who is alot more crash happy runs a BlueBird HS MG 626 fast and all metal can get them New for $30.. I bought a box of Hitecs along time ago for 100$ there was 12 used 900 servos in it..
#15
Fwiw, futaba may make a metal gear that would replace the nylon one. It would be for a different model but many times they will list the cross references somewhere. I dont remember the model numbers,but i have done this with some airtronics before.It may not be worth it to do this time but you can keep it in mind.



