R/C Tech Forums

R/C Tech Forums (https://www.rctech.net/forum/)
-   Nitro Off-Road (https://www.rctech.net/forum/nitro-off-road-130/)
-   -   MIP Bypass1 pistons for 1/8th scale (https://www.rctech.net/forum/nitro-off-road/1047566-mip-bypass1-pistons-1-8th-scale.html)

morgoth 08-01-2019 05:02 AM

MIP Bypass1 pistons for 1/8th scale
 
MIP released their Bypass1 pistons a while ago for Mugen and Associated, but since a few weeks they are also available for other brands.
I'm interested in them, but they are pretty expensive over here, so I'd like to hear some reviews before I buy a set.

Please let us know how they changed the car for you. Thanks!

xlrsd 08-02-2019 03:13 AM

If you don’t mind, I’d like to piggy back on this thread. I haven’t seen another one started for these. I also had a question. Are you supposed to build these new Bypass pistons using emulsion style, vented or not? Or maybe it doesn’t matter? Just curious as to what the intended shock build is for these new Bypass shock systems. Thanks all.

morgoth 08-02-2019 04:52 AM


Originally Posted by xlrsd (Post 15488696)
If you don’t mind, I’d like to piggy back on this thread. I haven’t seen another one started for these. I also had a question. Are you supposed to build these new Bypass pistons using emulsion style, vented or not? Or maybe it doesn’t matter? Just curious as to what the intended shock build is for these new Bypass shock systems. Thanks all.

It doesn't matter what style of shocks you use. They are normal pistons, but when the are moving out (rebound) the valve opens and it allows for faster rebound.
So basically you tune the compression ratio as you used to with shock oils and with the valves, you can speed up the rebound. This should give you a more responsive car with more grip in theory, but that's just theory.
I wonder what the experiences are of people that tried them in their cars.

xlrsd 08-03-2019 04:30 AM


Originally Posted by morgoth (Post 15488720)
It doesn't matter what style of shocks you use. They are normal pistons, but when the are moving out (rebound) the valve opens and it allows for faster rebound.
So basically you tune the compression ratio as you used to with shock oils and with the valves, you can speed up the rebound. This should give you a more responsive car with more grip in theory, but that's just theory.
I wonder what the experiences are of people that tried them in their cars.

ok, so they can be used with emulsion or bladder. I just didn’t know what more people were doing these days. I’m surprised you don’t hear more talk on these pistons, as they were suppose to change the hobby. Haha

RCSureStart 08-03-2019 04:53 AM

I did start this post back in March https://www.rctech.net/forum/nitro-o...s-pistons.html

I’ve been using the Bypass pistons in my HB D819 and have, along with the Performa bladders, noticed a huge improvement when racing. I find I’m able to push the buggy harder when cornering and it soaks up the ruts and bumps around the tracks I race at.


xlrsd 08-03-2019 05:59 AM

That’s what I’m saying! You started that thread back in March, and NO ONE else posted on it. Same with this one. Crickets. I guess no one runs these really, or have an opinion, or both. Lol

TheWorstDriver 08-03-2019 08:37 AM

I'm running these on a large outdoor very rutted track, and have noticed an increase of consistency in my lap times, and increased traction. They also help the car spring off the jumps a bit better. I think people are running them, but not wanting to expose the edge they give them. lol. I ran them on a smooth track, at a bigger race, and actually gained too much traction. I had to run tires that didnt hook up as well to free the car up in corners. Locally, I've TQ'd, and lapped the field with the setup posted below, results do matter to me. Cheers!

Front:
6 holes, (drilled out to 1.35), running BLUE washers @ 90+deg outside air, Track temp 102+deg, 600 CST Hudy oil

Rear:
6 holes, (drilled out to 1.35), running GREEN washers @ 90+deg outside air, Track temp 102+deg, 500 CST Hudy oil

xlrsd 08-03-2019 01:19 PM


Originally Posted by TheWorstDriver (Post 15489210)
I'm running these on a large outdoor very rutted track, and have noticed an increase of consistency in my lap times, and increased traction. They also help the car spring off the jumps a bit better. I think people are running them, but not wanting to expose the edge they give them. lol. I ran them on a smooth track, at a bigger race, and actually gained too much traction. I had to run tires that didnt hook up as well to free the car up in corners. Locally, I've TQ'd, and lapped the field with the setup posted below, results do matter to me. Cheers!

Front:
6 holes, (drilled out to 1.35), running BLUE washers @ 90+deg outside air, Track temp 102+deg, 600 CST Hudy oil

Rear:
6 holes, (drilled out to 1.35), running GREEN washers @ 90+deg outside air, Track temp 102+deg, 500 CST Hudy oil

Thanks for the info, worstdriver! That’s what I’m hoping to get out of them myself! It seems that what they are made to do makes a lot of sense, and just by looking at the physics involved in them alone, they MUST help. Your track also sounds pretty similar to my local track, so I think I’m gonna give your setup a try! Couple questions in regards to your setup: do you know what those Hudy oil weights are compared to Losi oils? That’s what I run. Also, do you run emulsion with that setup, or bladder?

windellmc 08-03-2019 04:03 PM

Drake and Maifield have them listed on their setup sheets.

xlrsd 08-03-2019 08:36 PM

It looks like most I’ve seen listed on pro setup sheets, when they are, are using emulsion.

petersen114 08-04-2019 11:31 AM

I have a set that I won in their giveaway. I would like to try them out in my T3 but don’t know which bladder to start out with.

frewster 08-04-2019 05:48 PM

These sound similar to the VRP pistons. I wonder how they compare in practice.

morgoth 08-05-2019 12:15 AM


Originally Posted by TheWorstDriver (Post 15489210)
I ran them on a smooth track, at a bigger race, and actually gained too much traction.

That's maybe one of the reasons why they aren't popular in Europe.
We have a lot of high speed tracks with good grip or multisurface tracks (with super high grip astro in it). I think the slower rebound of the stock pistons calm down the car and make it easier to drive in these conditions.
While the MIP pistons are probably good on low traction or blown out tracks.

xlrsd 08-05-2019 12:30 AM

So when guys installs these on their kits, what is a good start point? Do you keep the same weights of oil that you were running for track conditions in non-Bypass pistons? Is there a “neutral” oil weight to start with for Bypass pistons? And also with the different thickness gaskets, is there something you are supposed to START with so you don’t throw your shock set up so far out of wack changing from non-Bypass, to Bypass?

morgoth 08-05-2019 01:14 AM


Originally Posted by xlrsd (Post 15490027)
So when guys installs these on their kits, what is a good start point? Do you keep the same weights of oil that you were running for track conditions in non-Bypass pistons? Is there a “neutral” oil weight to start with for Bypass pistons? And also with the different thickness gaskets, is there something you are supposed to START with so you don’t throw your shock set up so far out of wack changing from non-Bypass, to Bypass?

Start with the size of holes and oils as in your normal shock setup is the recommendation from Adam Drake. He runs the clear valve in the front and blue in rear as a base setup.
And blue in the front/green in the rear if it's really blown out or loose.

token 08-05-2019 12:59 PM


Originally Posted by xlrsd (Post 15490027)
So when guys installs these on their kits, what is a good start point? Do you keep the same weights of oil that you were running for track conditions in non-Bypass pistons? Is there a “neutral” oil weight to start with for Bypass pistons? And also with the different thickness gaskets, is there something you are supposed to START with so you don’t throw your shock set up so far out of wack changing from non-Bypass, to Bypass?

Depends on your car as they make setupsfor different models. Run them with the same shock package you have now. We run blue front, green rear on the TLR.

sebtarta 08-05-2019 01:51 PM

Went to my local track, low bite clay track. Weather was nice and sunny which allowed the track to dry perfectly. Later clouds took over, humidity went up the roof and the track changed.

Grabbed the SRX8e with stock setup and 600CST 5 piston blue spring front and 500CST 5 piston pink spring rear. Slapped some Pro-Line Bow-Tie SS and turned some laps. Fastest I managed was a 27.4s, this was at around 12pm.

It was time to put the new shocks with the MIP bypass1 pistons. I built them with 600CST blue valve for front and 500CST green valve for rear. Same ride height as before 26mm front and 27mm rear and same tires again. Essentially everything was the same except the shock swap.

Unfortunately, by 2pm cloud overcast and it got very humid causing the track to be very heavy and loamy. Either way, I had to try it. Well fastest was 27.5s but the car was much better absorbing bumps, landing after a jump. Either way, I know that I could have been quicker probably, i just could not get the car moving as it felt heavy.

Will test more again next weekend as long as the weather cooperates. I did like the way how the car moved across the track absorbing all the bumps and holes in its path.

savage24x 08-05-2019 03:49 PM


Originally Posted by sebtarta (Post 15490338)
Went to my local track, low bite clay track. Weather was nice and sunny which allowed the track to dry perfectly. Later clouds took over, humidity went up the roof and the track changed.

Grabbed the SRX8e with stock setup and 600CST 5 piston blue spring front and 500CST 5 piston pink spring rear. Slapped some Pro-Line Bow-Tie SS and turned some laps. Fastest I managed was a 27.4s, this was at around 12pm.

It was time to put the new shocks with the MIP bypass1 pistons. I built them with 600CST blue valve for front and 500CST green valve for rear. Same ride height as before 26mm front and 27mm rear and same tires again. Essentially everything was the same except the shock swap.

Unfortunately, by 2pm cloud overcast and it got very humid causing the track to be very heavy and loamy. Either way, I had to try it. Well fastest was 27.5s but the car was much better absorbing bumps, landing after a jump. Either way, I know that I could have been quicker probably, i just could not get the car moving as it felt heavy.

Will test more again next weekend as long as the weather cooperates. I did like the way how the car moved across the track absorbing all the bumps and holes in its path.

Glad to see you didn't run 500/300... that's one wacky setup :smile:

jhold87 08-05-2019 07:12 PM

So much rain
 
I won a set of them on Facebook, was planning on testing them this past weekend but with all the rain I didn't get to run. Tomorrow and Wednesday after work I plan on testing for several hours both day's so only time will tell. I just installed the M2C o-ring pistons and haven't tested those either so should be fun tomorrow and Wednesday. I will be keeping a ton of notes.

TheWorstDriver 08-08-2019 09:58 AM


Originally Posted by sebtarta (Post 15490338)
Went to my local track, low bite clay track. Weather was nice and sunny which allowed the track to dry perfectly. Later clouds took over, humidity went up the roof and the track changed.

Grabbed the SRX8e with stock setup and 600CST 5 piston blue spring front and 500CST 5 piston pink spring rear. Slapped some Pro-Line Bow-Tie SS and turned some laps. Fastest I managed was a 27.4s, this was at around 12pm.

It was time to put the new shocks with the MIP bypass1 pistons. I built them with 600CST blue valve for front and 500CST green valve for rear. Same ride height as before 26mm front and 27mm rear and same tires again. Essentially everything was the same except the shock swap.

Unfortunately, by 2pm cloud overcast and it got very humid causing the track to be very heavy and loamy. Either way, I had to try it. Well fastest was 27.5s but the car was much better absorbing bumps, landing after a jump. Either way, I know that I could have been quicker probably, i just could not get the car moving as it felt heavy.

Will test more again next weekend as long as the weather cooperates. I did like the way how the car moved across the track absorbing all the bumps and holes in its path.

This is exactly what I felt the first time I ran them, I describe that is "too easy to drive" or "feels slower", but I forced myself to race them anyway. In almost every race I had less major mistakes, resulting in more consistency, not more speed. In one club race, the car became so easy to drive, and "slow", that I lapped the field in 7 minutes, and never once went off track. So i'm struggling with the fact that it feels slower, but its actually faster on our large and super rutted outdoor track. It just doesn't seem right. lol.

Edit for after thought,... I forgot to mention that later on when I went one step up in hardness on my tires, it free'd the car back up for better rotation in corners. I went from soft long wear AKA compound to medium compound and she took off again. The harder compound tire also stayed more consistent, again increasing constancy.

TheWorstDriver 08-08-2019 10:13 AM


Originally Posted by xlrsd (Post 15489313)

Thanks for the info, worstdriver! That’s what I’m hoping to get out of them myself! It seems that what they are made to do makes a lot of sense, and just by looking at the physics involved in them alone, they MUST help. Your track also sounds pretty similar to my local track, so I think I’m gonna give your setup a try! Couple questions in regards to your setup: do you know what those Hudy oil weights are compared to Losi oils? That’s what I run. Also, do you run emulsion with that setup, or bladder?

I don't know the Hudy/Losi conversion, but dont they offer a CST rating on the bottle now? I'd match them up, I think CST is a standard measurement regardless of brand. Maybe someone else can chime in.

I run Xray 2019 stock (clear waffle) bladders, but I am currently testing the new harder compound (RED waffle) Xray bladders. Not enough data/results to recommend.

largeorangefont 08-08-2019 10:21 AM

Which ones are you guys going with? I want to try the 6 hole pistons, but the AE version comes with 8 hole pistons, leaning towards just getting the Mugen set for my AE car.

TheWorstDriver 08-08-2019 10:36 AM


Originally Posted by largeorangefont (Post 15491671)
Which ones are you guys going with? I want to try the 6 hole pistons, but the AE version comes with 8 hole pistons, leaning towards just getting the Mugen set for my AE car.

I found the 6 hole set I ordered, and am running in the Xray 2019 XB8.

Part# FPR18400

https://www.amainhobbies.com/flash-p...00/p961498?r=0


sebtarta 08-08-2019 01:09 PM

Also my 600 and 500 CST is using the PT RC Racing oils.

largeorangefont 08-08-2019 01:38 PM


Originally Posted by TheWorstDriver (Post 15491680)
I found the 6 hole set I ordered, and am running in the Xray 2019 XB8.

Part# FPR18400

https://www.amainhobbies.com/flash-p...00/p961498?r=0

Just ordered the same part.

largeorangefont 08-23-2019 03:13 PM

Ok I'm installing these and the MIP pistons are dragging in the shock bodies. The Kyosho and AE pistions I've ran previously don't drag at all. Same problem with 2 separate shock bodies.

Anyone else had this issue? I'm about to get some 1500 grit sandpaper and fit them by hand but this seems a little annoying for a $40 set of shock pistons.

morgoth 08-23-2019 03:16 PM


Originally Posted by largeorangefont (Post 15499090)
Ok I'm installing these and the MIP pistons are dragging in the shock bodies. The Kyosho and AE pistions I've ran previously don't drag at all. Anyone else had this issue? I'm about to get some 1500 grit sandpaper and fit them by hand but this seems a little annoying for a $40 set of shock pistons.

I received my set earlier this week and I installed them yesterday. They are perfect fit in my Mugen shocks.
These pistons are 15.9mm diameter, so it's a close fit. If the shock body is dry, it's normal that they drag a bit. It's same with my stock Mugen pistons. But once you fill up with oil, it should move smoothly.

largeorangefont 08-23-2019 03:23 PM


Originally Posted by morgoth (Post 15499094)
I received my set earlier this week and I installed them yesterday. They are perfect fit in my Mugen shocks.
These pistons are 15.9mm diameter, so it's a close fit. If the shock body is dry, it's normal that they drag a bit. It's same with my stock Mugen pistons. But once you fill up with oil, it should move smoothly.

Ok I am good now. I loosened the nut holding the piston a bit, and the shocks feel great. Lesson learned - just lightly snug the nuts that hold the pistons.

TurnNBurn 08-24-2019 10:47 AM

If you guys haven’t seen it, I highly recommend you look for Adam Drake’s YouTube video on them that he posted a few weeks back. He gets into some detail on how it has benefitted their race program over at Mugen Seiki, and was a good watch, IMHO.

From a theoretical standpoint, this design makes a lot of sense. I’ve done a lot of Sim Racing over the past 10 years, and in on-road applications, controlling rebound can really allow you to fine tune how the car responds to weight transfer, primarily front /rear (which directly affects grip level on entry/exit) - so any of you also running in the on-road GT8 class with cars based on buggy designs can experiment with this as well. As for how it benefits in off-road? I think Adam did a pretty good job of explaining that in his video. 🙂

EDIT: BTW, it’s also interesting that you can flip the assembly around, favoring the adjustment of compression over rebound, but for most racing applications, you’d probably want to have more control over rebound. MÍP calls this bypass1... and in their video, they mentioned further evolution - perhaps they are experimenting with finer control over BOTH rebound and compression? 🤔

savage24x 09-02-2019 08:27 AM

What’s the diameter of the HB racing pistons? How do they compare to Mugen?

BHutch 09-02-2019 10:04 AM


Originally Posted by savage24x (Post 15503845)
What’s the diameter of the HB racing pistons? How do they compare to Mugen?

https://cimg8.ibsrv.net/gimg/www.rct...45e8ce96d4.png

savage24x 09-03-2019 05:18 AM


Originally Posted by BHutch (Post 15503884)

You are awesome!!!!!

sebtarta 09-03-2019 10:17 AM

All good but $26 for 4 pistons is a bit much to be honest.

largeorangefont 09-03-2019 10:31 AM


Originally Posted by sebtarta (Post 15504481)
All good but $26 for 4 pistons is a bit much to be honest.

Eustace is proud of his shit. :)

E1 Diablo 09-15-2019 06:43 AM

Anyone else notice the plastic insert "wrinkle" when you tighten the nut to hold the piston in?

morgoth 09-15-2019 08:00 AM


Originally Posted by E1 Diablo (Post 15510920)
Anyone else notice the plastic insert "wrinkle" when you tighten the nut to hold the piston in?

Do you mean the flap or the bushing?
if it’s the flap, you have the piston upside down. If it’s the bushing, you’re over tightening it.

E1 Diablo 09-15-2019 12:31 PM

The piston is installed correctly... and it's not over tightened...

BrokenFrontArm 09-15-2019 02:07 PM


Originally Posted by E1 Diablo (Post 15511062)
The piston is installed correctly... and it's not over tightened...

Since there are no pictures to show how the pistons are installed and how the valves are wrinkled, I can only tell from my own experience that the installation instructions that come with the pistons are not very clear, and I installed the pistons upside down for the first time and was wondering why the valves got all wrinkled. Then I watched the instruction and videos from MIP web page again and noticed that the flat side should be facing up, not the side with "MIP" text, after that the valves were nicely flat. As said, I don't know if this is what happened in your case, but worth checking one more time

morgoth 09-15-2019 02:54 PM


Originally Posted by E1 Diablo (Post 15511062)
The piston is installed correctly... and it's not over tightened...

maybe post a picture because I don’t know what the issue could be then.
i don’t have problems with my pistons, so I suppose something went wrong during assembly.

E1 Diablo 09-16-2019 07:54 AM



All times are GMT -7. It is currently 12:21 PM.

Powered By: vBulletin v3.9.3.8
Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.