Motor shorted?
#1
Thread Starter
Tech Regular
Joined: May 2012
Posts: 398
From: Hamburg
Last week I ran my B5m and one of the motor wires broke.
Now, after soldering on a new wire, I noticed that my car was rolling with a lot of resistance. After further inspection I found out that it was the motor. When I turn the rotor it feels as if the motor is braking constantly (like when you connect the motor wires to each other).
I suspect that the motor got too hot and burned the coating of the stator wires, leading to a winding short circuit. Could this be the reason or is something else amiss?
I did not try to run the motor on the track for fear of damaging the ESC, but it does still work.
Now, after soldering on a new wire, I noticed that my car was rolling with a lot of resistance. After further inspection I found out that it was the motor. When I turn the rotor it feels as if the motor is braking constantly (like when you connect the motor wires to each other).
I suspect that the motor got too hot and burned the coating of the stator wires, leading to a winding short circuit. Could this be the reason or is something else amiss?
I did not try to run the motor on the track for fear of damaging the ESC, but it does still work.
#2
Joined: Sep 2009
Posts: 5,368
From: Central Wisconsin USA
Last week I ran my B5m and one of the motor wires broke.
Now, after soldering on a new wire, I noticed that my car was rolling with a lot of resistance. After further inspection I found out that it was the motor. When I turn the rotor it feels as if the motor is braking constantly (like when you connect the motor wires to each other).
I suspect that the motor got too hot and burned the coating of the stator wires, leading to a winding short circuit. Could this be the reason or is something else amiss?
I did not try to run the motor on the track for fear of damaging the ESC, but it does still work.
Now, after soldering on a new wire, I noticed that my car was rolling with a lot of resistance. After further inspection I found out that it was the motor. When I turn the rotor it feels as if the motor is braking constantly (like when you connect the motor wires to each other).
I suspect that the motor got too hot and burned the coating of the stator wires, leading to a winding short circuit. Could this be the reason or is something else amiss?
I did not try to run the motor on the track for fear of damaging the ESC, but it does still work.
#3
Thread Starter
Tech Regular
Joined: May 2012
Posts: 398
From: Hamburg
That can't be the reason because this motor doesn't have your typical soldering tabs like a Reedy for example.
I opened up the motor and it looks a bit burned inside. Interestingly, only 2 of the 3 poles on the stator look burned and not the 2 connected to the wire that broke.




I opened up the motor and it looks a bit burned inside. Interestingly, only 2 of the 3 poles on the stator look burned and not the 2 connected to the wire that broke.
#7
I agree with Roelof, it maybe the ESC. Breaking a wire on the motor could cause it to loose memory of calibration. The ESC lost it home position when wire broke. It become flaky. Start from beginning of Binding and calibration, just reset. As for heat causing the disconnecting at solder joints, poor soldering and overgearing.
#8
If while the motor is in your hand, NONE of the A B C wires are bridged with solder, and you spin the motor and it feels "tight" or "sticky" it's shorted.
This is essentially how brake is made by shorting out the phases. If it feels like that, sorry to say it's likely bad.
This is essentially how brake is made by shorting out the phases. If it feels like that, sorry to say it's likely bad.




