Steering exponential
#1
Thread Starter
Tech Apprentice
Joined: Jul 2012
Posts: 93
I'm after a perfectly linear feel to the steering in my AE B6.
I've always used -ve expo on my KO Propo EX-10, normally around -15%. I'm questioning if this is enough.
What puzzles me is reading/hearing people say 'I don't use expo because I like the linear feel'.
The servos we use in cars do not provide a linear lateral output. The servo moves through an arc, mechanically the movement around centre is greater at given input than at the extremity of travel. Therefore 0% expo on a transmitter equals positive mechanical expo.
What complicates things in a buggy is it's not just the servo horn that moves in an arc, so do the crank and hubs.
Am I right in thinking if I achieve a perfectly linear lateral movement for the horn, this will effectively translate to linear movement through the rest of the system?
-46% expo seems to be spot on for the horn.
I've always used -ve expo on my KO Propo EX-10, normally around -15%. I'm questioning if this is enough.
What puzzles me is reading/hearing people say 'I don't use expo because I like the linear feel'.
The servos we use in cars do not provide a linear lateral output. The servo moves through an arc, mechanically the movement around centre is greater at given input than at the extremity of travel. Therefore 0% expo on a transmitter equals positive mechanical expo.
What complicates things in a buggy is it's not just the servo horn that moves in an arc, so do the crank and hubs.
Am I right in thinking if I achieve a perfectly linear lateral movement for the horn, this will effectively translate to linear movement through the rest of the system?
-46% expo seems to be spot on for the horn.
Last edited by 2hundy; 01-06-2017 at 07:10 AM.
#2
I usually run at least enough exponential curve on the steering to make up for the positive mechanical expo you describe. Do what works for you!
You could use a setup station to measure the wheel lock versus transmitter wheel motion if you truly wanted to get as close as possible to a linear response. You'll never get it perfect, of course, because there's no guarantee the transmitter curve will match all of the non-linearities created by the linkages, and then of course there's Ackerman, so which wheel should you measure?
You could use a setup station to measure the wheel lock versus transmitter wheel motion if you truly wanted to get as close as possible to a linear response. You'll never get it perfect, of course, because there's no guarantee the transmitter curve will match all of the non-linearities created by the linkages, and then of course there's Ackerman, so which wheel should you measure?
#3
Tech Regular
Joined: Nov 2014
Posts: 378
Having in mind that 1:1 cars implicitly have mechanical steering expo and it does not seem to be a big deal, I would tend to say having 0% tx expo would be most like the steering feel in 1:1 cars. There is no such thing like 100% linear steering as far as rotating parts are involved, which is always in conventional car steering.
#4
Tech Regular
iTrader: (7)
Joined: Jan 2013
Posts: 341
Buddies who have driven my cars always comment it is easy to drive and "dialed" - sometimes i can't even drive theirs it is so twitchy / sensitive.




