ESC power capacitor question
#1
Is there any advantage/disadvantage of using a capacitor of higher value than what came stock with my esc? I am using a Speed Passion Reventon Pro. It came with a 2200uf 16v 105* capacitor. Would a capacitor with a higher uf and/or voltage value help/hurt or not make a difference? Is there an advantage of using multiple capacitors vs 1 of equivalent value?
If it matters, the car is 2wd, 17.5 "blinky" buggy, w/ 5.05 FDR, 3" battery leads, and 70C batteries.
If it matters, the car is 2wd, 17.5 "blinky" buggy, w/ 5.05 FDR, 3" battery leads, and 70C batteries.
#2
Higher voltage or capacitance ratings will increase the ripple current capability, which is very important in this application. This lets the capacitors run cooler and extends their life. Make sure you use capacitors designed for high ripple current! Most manufacturers have at least one type that is optimized for this.
Multiple smaller capacitors (of the same total value and rating as a single large capacitor) have a higher surface area / volume ratio, and this also lets them run cooler. They might be easier to fit into tight spots, too!
Multiple smaller capacitors (of the same total value and rating as a single large capacitor) have a higher surface area / volume ratio, and this also lets them run cooler. They might be easier to fit into tight spots, too!
#3
Tech Champion

Joined: Oct 2007
Posts: 7,342
Higher capacitance low ESR is certainly good, several ESC manufacturers offer higher capacity caps as an upgrade. At least some are multiple caps in parallel. Should lower ESC temps and improve braking feel and consistency as I understand it.
Does a higher voltage rating help?
Does a higher voltage rating help?
#4
Tech Fanatic
iTrader: (13)
Joined: Oct 2011
Posts: 875
From: Round Lake, IL
Higher voltage ratings will prevent the cap from undergoing electrolysis at the plates when high-frequency garbage (like ripple currents) hit the caps. Electrolysis = Gas = Boom!
Higher capacitance will only help to a degree, and you probably won't really notice it, but your ESC might stutter less. Low ESR will help keep temps down.
Higher capacitance will only help to a degree, and you probably won't really notice it, but your ESC might stutter less. Low ESR will help keep temps down.
#6
Higher capacitance low ESR is certainly good, several ESC manufacturers offer higher capacity caps as an upgrade. At least some are multiple caps in parallel. Should lower ESC temps and improve braking feel and consistency as I understand it.
Does a higher voltage rating help?
Does a higher voltage rating help?
#7
equivalent series resistance
http://www.radio-electronics.com/inf...ial-basics.php
also pretty good definition and breakdown here, a little more in depth
http://www.illinoiscapacitor.com/pdf...or_fiction.pdf
http://www.radio-electronics.com/inf...ial-basics.php
also pretty good definition and breakdown here, a little more in depth
http://www.illinoiscapacitor.com/pdf...or_fiction.pdf
#10
OK, guys, please forgive the repetitive questions. I am still trying to wrap my head around the esc cap issue. It's been literally 40 years since I installed maintained, troubleshot, and qc'd voice and data communication circuits, so my basic electricity is a little foggy. The stock cap is rated at 2200uf 25v (not 16v like I posted earlier) 105* high temp.
From a rc car perspective, will I gain noticable more punch, smother braking, and lower temps from running a single aftermarket cap rated at 2200uf, 35v, ESR 0.1206 ohms and a ripple current of 2880 ma, or four 470uf 35v ESR 0.494 ohms and a ripple current of 900ma wired in parallel. OR, am I over thinking the problem, and just run the stock cap or their high power 4 cap bank (four 470uf 16v caps)
Thanks for any feedback
From a rc car perspective, will I gain noticable more punch, smother braking, and lower temps from running a single aftermarket cap rated at 2200uf, 35v, ESR 0.1206 ohms and a ripple current of 2880 ma, or four 470uf 35v ESR 0.494 ohms and a ripple current of 900ma wired in parallel. OR, am I over thinking the problem, and just run the stock cap or their high power 4 cap bank (four 470uf 16v caps)

Thanks for any feedback
#11
Tech Initiate
iTrader: (4)
Joined: May 2011
Posts: 47
From: KNoxville, TN
Ok so. I guess back to even more basics to help my understanding.
DC powered battery (supply) goes through the esc comes out as 3 waves phase shifted 120 degrees (ac?) Clipped as a trapezoid wave with no negative alternation?
If that statement is true then the ripple current seen is usually from ac to DC conversion in power supply circuits. Therefore where are we seeing ripple current from? A back feed from the motor?
And to muddy the water more resistors in parallel divides resistance. So putting caps in parallel makes the ESR divide as well??? Lowering ESR will give a small bump in current adding to the "punch"? Based on lower resistance increases current?
Lost in electrons
Gary
DC powered battery (supply) goes through the esc comes out as 3 waves phase shifted 120 degrees (ac?) Clipped as a trapezoid wave with no negative alternation?
If that statement is true then the ripple current seen is usually from ac to DC conversion in power supply circuits. Therefore where are we seeing ripple current from? A back feed from the motor?
And to muddy the water more resistors in parallel divides resistance. So putting caps in parallel makes the ESR divide as well??? Lowering ESR will give a small bump in current adding to the "punch"? Based on lower resistance increases current?
Lost in electrons
Gary
Last edited by ariwere; 07-18-2013 at 08:51 AM.
#12
From a rc car perspective, will I gain noticable more punch, smother braking, and lower temps from running a single aftermarket cap rated at 2200uf, 35v, ESR 0.1206 ohms and a ripple current of 2880 ma, or four 470uf 35v ESR 0.494 ohms and a ripple current of 900ma wired in parallel.
#13
Putting caps in parallel does divide the ESR for the combination. But this usually won't result in any perceptible increase in "punch" (power), as the commutation frequency is too low for the caps to supply current for a significant length of time.
Last edited by howardcano; 07-18-2013 at 11:26 AM.
#15
No, that can only power the receiver and other electronics. A receiver battery isn't allowed to supply power to the motor. The main battery still sees all of the high currents drawn by the motor.



1Likes