Do brushless motors have the same performance regardless of direction?
#1
Just curious....can I flip the motor wires and run a reverse rotation (clockwise) and it have the same performance as it running counter-clockwise?
#8
Joined: Jun 2008
Posts: 3,891
From: anywhere I can race 2wd dirt,and 1/12 onroad in MI.
any thing that is sensored usually has a reverse direction function in the esc.(i know my novaks do) But non sensored motors without adjustable endbell timing are set at 0 deg. so they are neutral and will run and perform just as well in either direction. Especially mini motors such as mamba, tekin,and the ammo motors. In these systems timing is all taken care of via the software within the controller.
But if you try and swap the A and C wires on a sensored system you will get an error message from the esc (light blinks) indicating that it is wired wrong.
Also keep in mind that with sensored systems, even if you use the reverse rotation feature , if you have moved the mechanical timing on the end bell it WILL runn better in one direction than the other.I found this out because i usually run my 17.5's with the timing retarded to produce more torque and cooler temps for running dirt. Well I set up a new XBR speedo for a car and you could hear it was running faster in reverse than it would in forward.
so If you reverse direction on the motor remember that if you want to play with the mechanical timing for tuning that it is backwards
IE clockwise to retard, counterclockwise to advance when it is normally counter clockwise to retard and clockwise to advance.
But if you try and swap the A and C wires on a sensored system you will get an error message from the esc (light blinks) indicating that it is wired wrong.
Also keep in mind that with sensored systems, even if you use the reverse rotation feature , if you have moved the mechanical timing on the end bell it WILL runn better in one direction than the other.I found this out because i usually run my 17.5's with the timing retarded to produce more torque and cooler temps for running dirt. Well I set up a new XBR speedo for a car and you could hear it was running faster in reverse than it would in forward.
so If you reverse direction on the motor remember that if you want to play with the mechanical timing for tuning that it is backwards
IE clockwise to retard, counterclockwise to advance when it is normally counter clockwise to retard and clockwise to advance.
#9
Running reverse direction.....
If you are dealing with a SENSORLESS motor then the awnser is NO there is no difference.
If SENSORED then YES direction does matter because the motor sensors are timed, if you would like further proof then read the Tekin RS thread which explains that... almost no sensored motors have the sensor array timed at 0
If you are dealing with a SENSORLESS motor then the awnser is NO there is no difference.
If SENSORED then YES direction does matter because the motor sensors are timed, if you would like further proof then read the Tekin RS thread which explains that... almost no sensored motors have the sensor array timed at 0




