R/C Tech Forums

R/C Tech Forums (https://www.rctech.net/forum/)
-   Offroad Nitro Engine Forum (https://www.rctech.net/forum/offroad-nitro-engine-forum-157/)
-   -   nitro engine poll round 2...... (https://www.rctech.net/forum/offroad-nitro-engine-forum/445367-nitro-engine-poll-round-2-a.html)

TopGearRC 10-22-2010 09:52 PM


Originally Posted by J.Whiting (Post 8099586)
ok here is going to be a thread for fun... if in any way it becomes a bashing thread it will be gone..

rule #1 vote for your favorite engine brand..
rule #2 no fighting.. pick an engine and vote..
rule #3 rules subject to change...
rule #4 not all engines are on here sorry.. max of 10 choices... i took the readers "choice" for the 6 new motors added
rule #5 pick other engine not listed for yours.. again sorry 10 choices only...

remember this is only for fun.. please keep it that way... i dont know if this thread will last long but worth a shot to see what is the most popular engine you guys run... the last thread was good.. you guys where keeping it very clean and productive.. lets keep this one also....



If we have a round 3 can you list the most popular engine models instead of the engine manufacturer which produces a number of good and some bad engines. For that I nominate

Werks B5
Nova +4
Nova P5
OS Vspec
OS Speed
Go 5port
Alpha green head
Team Orion alpha
RB Killer Nine
Picco EVO 4

J.Whiting 10-23-2010 01:44 PM


Originally Posted by xjqkz (Post 8110528)
If we have a round 3 can you list the most popular engine models instead of the engine manufacturer which produces a number of good and some bad engines. For that I nominate

Werks B5
Nova +4
Nova P5
OS Vspec
OS Speed
Go 5port
Alpha green head
Team Orion alpha
RB Killer Nine
Picco EVO 4

i dont think that would work due to you have 10 engines now and there is no werks b6... no rg by os. 2 different alpha engines. 6 different rb engines.. the list would be way to long to make a pol of just 10 and have even 50% of the guys happy.. this way general brands will keep all the motors for the most part in the game..

blktransam 10-23-2010 02:16 PM

I do find it funny how axial made the list and NOT JS......ahh man I love it!!

J.Whiting 10-23-2010 02:28 PM


Originally Posted by blktransam (Post 8112532)
I do find it funny how axial made the list and NOT JS......ahh man I love it!!

me too... wait a minute:eek: i made this poll :cry:... i went back thru the first poll and these are the brands/motors guys wanted to see on the list... this is my point:weird: there are so many good engines that we as consumers argue so much on which brand/motor is better... they all have different feel, power and so on... we should all be happy to have so many choices to run...

motomatt 10-23-2010 02:28 PM


Originally Posted by blktransam (Post 8112532)
I do find it funny how axial made the list and NOT JS......ahh man I love it!!

You had to be here at the 1st poll to get it.

Jomo918 10-23-2010 03:19 PM


Originally Posted by blktransam (Post 8112532)
I do find it funny how axial made the list and NOT JS......ahh man I love it!!

You have to remember this forum isn't just for racers! Axial is pretty popular engine for the bashers, and monster truck guys!:nod:

McWolf 10-23-2010 04:24 PM

I do understand that this thread is supposed to be a poll, and I do not wish to undermine Mr Whitling's work in any way since I believe that this is a great thread. However, the thought crossed my mind that forum members could post their top three favourite engine brands, which may allow a wider range of engine brands to be available for all participating members to peruse/comment. Just a thought... :)

J.Whiting 10-23-2010 04:27 PM


Originally Posted by McWolf (Post 8112848)
I do understand that this thread is supposed to be a poll, and I do not wish to undermine Mr Whitling's work in any way since I believe that this is a great thread. However, the thought crossed my mind that forum members could post their top three favourite engine brands, which may allow a wider range of engine brands to be available for all participating members to peruse/comment. Just a thought... :)

i am not against it just there are so many choices to choose from... if there was a way to make a 10 motor field i would go to round three but just my opinion it there is 20 very good motors from 10 motor brands... lets see what happens...

sluggo_sx8 10-23-2010 04:45 PM


Originally Posted by J.Whiting (Post 8112558)
me too... wait a minute:eek: i made this poll :cry:... i went back thru the first poll and these are the brands/motors guys wanted to see on the list... this is my point:weird: there are so many good engines that we as consumers argue so much on which brand/motor is better... they all have different feel, power and so on... we should all be happy to have so many choices to run...

You are right, we are very lucky to have so many to choose from. Start flying nitro helis and you have 3 or 4 to choose from and that is it!

Cool to see how close the top 3 are staying. I thought a few of the others would have alot more hits by now.

Jaz240 10-23-2010 05:05 PM

Its good for the hobby to see some many engines getting votes. Even though we all pretty much knew that OS, Werks, and Nova would lead the way. When engine companies see that there may not be a clear favorite it will keep them competitive and keep producing quality mills at an affordable price. ( at least I hope so ) Its also nice for me to see how many votes Go has recieved. Not to start trouble but I have been hearing horror stories about them from day one and this poll has proven to me that all the negative things I have heard have to be nothing more than false rumors. I am sure nobody would have voted for any engine that was worthy in some fashion. I am actually now thinking about the possibility of trying one of the new Go engines based solely on the votes of this pole

shanem121 10-23-2010 05:08 PM


Originally Posted by Jaz240 (Post 8112972)
Its good for the hobby to see some many engines getting votes. Even though we all pretty much knew that OS, Werks, and Nova would lead the way. When engine companies see that there may not be a clear favorite it will keep them competitive and keep producing quality mills at an affordable price. ( at least I hope so ) Its also nice for me to see how many votes Go has recieved. Not to start trouble but I have been hearing horror stories about them from day one and this poll has proven to me that all the negative things I have heard have to be nothing more than false rumors. I am sure nobody would have voted for any engine that was worthy in some fashion. I am actually now thinking about the possibility of trying one of the new Go engines based solely on the votes of this pole

I agree 110% with you James.

Jomo918 10-23-2010 05:09 PM


Originally Posted by Jaz240 (Post 8112972)
Its good for the hobby to see some many engines getting votes. Even though we all pretty much knew that OS, Werks, and Nova would lead the way. When engine companies see that there may not be a clear favorite it will keep them competitive and keep producing quality mills at an affordable price. ( at least I hope so ) Its also nice for me to see how many votes Go has recieved. Not to start trouble but I have been hearing horror stories about them from day one and this poll has proven to me that all the negative things I have heard have to be nothing more than false rumors. I am sure nobody would have voted for any engine that was worthy in some fashion. I am actually now thinking about the possibility of trying one of the new Go engines based solely on the votes of this pole

See that's what this is all about, your getting hundreds of opinions in one thread!

Werks 10-23-2010 05:59 PM

Jeremy, if I could makema suggestion it would be to do just like what you did after the 1st poll. Take the top five brands for the next poll and take 2 engines from each brand and run a poll on them. Either that or do a seperate poll listing 10 different engines do the first poll for buggy and then another poll for truggy, all depends on how detailed you want to be.


Jaz240, I have to agree with you that the results are a little surprising to me also. Speaking now strictly about the US I have a pretty good idead about what most peoples sales are like. I think this thread is a little skewed because its a global forum, so there are people on it from all over the world. This affects the stats a bit i think because if you for instance take my sales into accout, about 95% of our business is in north america so we do verry little sales outside the US right now. Some of the brands like OS and Nova are more global, brands such as Go I think are more established in Australia etc. Etc. If you forminstance look at RB they to me have pretty much disapeared here in the US over the last couple of years (a personal oppinion just based on what i see at the tracks) but they are still doing ok in the poll which I can understand because in Europe and some parts of Asia they are a strong brand. So as mentioned I think that demographics plays a role in these results.

I should add that just to be clear nothing that I'm saying is meant to be negative (about any brand) it's just an observation that i am making based on the results that I am seeing here and is not meant in any way to offend anyone. Just adding that in there:)

Jomo918 10-23-2010 06:18 PM


Originally Posted by Werks (Post 8113097)
Jeremy, if I could makema suggestion it would be to do just like what you did after the 1st poll. Take the top five brands for the next poll and take 2 engines from each brand and run a poll on them. Either that or do a seperate poll listing 10 different engines do the first poll for buggy and then another poll for truggy, all depends on how detailed you want to be.


Jaz240, I have to agree with you that the results are a little surprising to me also. Speaking now strictly about the US I have a pretty good idead about what most peoples sales are like. I think this thread is a little skewed because its a global forum, so there are people on it from all over the world. This affects the stats a bit i think because if you for instance take my sales into accout, about 95% of our business is in north america so we do verry little sales outside the US right now. Some of the brands like OS and Nova are more global, brands such as Go I think are more established in Australia etc. Etc. If you forminstance look at RB they to me have pretty much disapeared here in the US over the last couple of years (a personal oppinion just based on what i see at the tracks) but they are still doing ok in the poll which I can understand because in Europe and some parts of Asia they are a strong brand. So as mentioned I think that demographics plays a role in these results.

I should add that just to be clear nothing that I'm saying is meant to be negative (about any brand) it's just an observation that i am making based on the results that I am seeing here and is not meant in any way to offend anyone. Just adding that in there:)

But the thing is even tho the brands are sorta skewed due to the popularity in the perticular country, we as well as almost all the other countries out there can buy a werks, or a go, etc. We choose not to bc we want to run what has a proven track record or what fits our budget. RB is dying bc there priced high and performance isn't any better then there rivals. I believe werks has really caused RB's slide to happen even quicker here in the states! It's hard to beat the price and performance of a werks!:nod:

MAGPIE-121 10-23-2010 06:59 PM

:lol: sorry to say mr werks, but the GO sales in the US have gone through the roof with the release of the GX & MG range of motors & with 2 MGs qualifying for the worlds in pattaya in november these motors are now up there with the best of them. this poll is suppose to be fun, & to gauge what people like from their experience with different motors, not for the company men to use for marketing purposes as only a small percentage of us nitro nuts will find this thread anyway ;) from my experience the OS, NOVA & RB are great motors but for $ value against reliability & performance i can't go past the GO range. all brands have there lemons & newbies that give a brand negative feeback. most motors on the market today, in the right hands, can win a major event ! the growth of our hobby is testament to the quality that is avaliable out there at the moment JMO :D:lol::cool:

JAMMINKRAZY 10-23-2010 07:31 PM

I say leave this poll going for awhile. I think pretty much all of the engines that were requested are in this one. Let it run and see what happens after a couple months or so, maybe even a year. Could be interesting!:nod:

Jomo918 10-23-2010 07:50 PM

Leave it....leave it......leave it.....leave it......:lol::lol::lol::D:D:D

Werks 10-23-2010 08:34 PM


Originally Posted by MAGPIE-121 (Post 8113274)
:lol: sorry to say mr werks, but the GO sales in the US have gone through the roof with the release of the GX & MG range of motors & with 2 MGs qualifying for the worlds in pattaya in november these motors are now up there with the best of them. this poll is suppose to be fun, & to gauge what people like from their experience with different motors, not for the company men to use for marketing purposes as only a small percentage of us nitro nuts will find this thread anyway ;) from my experience the OS, NOVA & RB are great motors but for $ value against reliability & performance i can't go past the GO range. all brands have there lemons & newbies that give a brand negative feeback. most motors on the market today, in the right hands, can win a major event ! the growth of our hobby is testament to the quality that is avaliable out there at the moment JMO :D:lol::cool:

Please lets try to keep this friendly as I'm not trying to start another pointless debate about who's stuff may or may not be better or whos stuff is selling better etc etc. because at the end of the day it frankly does not really matter.

Werks 10-23-2010 11:19 PM


Originally Posted by Werks (Post 8113591)
Please lets try to keep this friendly as I'm not trying to start another pointless debate about who's stuff may or may not be better or whos stuff is selling better etc etc. because at the end of the day it frankly does not really matter.

And just to be clear what I meant by that was I was just talking in general about the poll in my earlier post and that was it. So please lets just keep things friendly so this thread does not go off on a tangent also :nod::)

deadmancourt 10-23-2010 11:32 PM

lots of great feedback here...I CANT WAIT TO SEE WHAT DRIVER & ENGINE WIN THE WORLDS!:nod:....

Werks 10-23-2010 11:38 PM


Originally Posted by deadmancourt (Post 8114014)
lots of great feedback here...I CANT WAIT TO SEE WHAT DRIVER & ENGINE WIN THE WORLDS!:nod:....

Yep me too. At that level though there are about 10 or 12 guys that can win and having seen how challenging the track is I think that it is probably going to come down to who has the least amount of problems and needs to be turn marshaled the least. So a bit of luck is going to be involved here!

deadmancourt 10-23-2010 11:41 PM


Originally Posted by Werks (Post 8114023)
Yep me too. At that level though there are about 10 or 12 guys that can win and having seen how challenging the track is I think that it is probably going to come down to who has the least amount of problems and needs to be turn marshaled the least. So a bit of luck is going to be involved here!

thats for sure!...its gonna come down to whos car doesnt break:lol::lol:....but the track will be different from the practice...you know that right?.....

Jaz240 10-23-2010 11:41 PM

i would love to see someone with like an STS or an old Caster grenade win just so everyone shuts the hell up :D

deadmancourt 10-23-2010 11:44 PM


Originally Posted by Jaz240 (Post 8114025)
i would love to see someone with like an STS or an old Caster grenade win just so everyone shuts the hell up :D

i was just stating that im REALLY anxious to see...not meaning to prove anything....just anxious :D

Jaz240 10-23-2010 11:49 PM

I know. My post was not meant at you. Just saying "in general " we can then have facts to shove in peoples faces when they ( insert name here ) start bragging that their engine is the best. Truth is the right driver can win with any engine and/or any chassis with the right set/up, some dedication, a good strategy and some luck

Werks 10-23-2010 11:58 PM


Originally Posted by Jaz240 (Post 8114036)
I know. My post was not meant at you. Just saying "in general " we can then have facts to shove in peoples faces when they ( insert name here ) start bragging that their engine is the best. Truth is the right driver can win with any engine and/or any chassis with the right set/up, some dedication, a good strategy and some luck

True but STS or Caster :weird::confused::weird: Ain't gonna happen! :ha:

hambone 10-24-2010 12:10 AM


Originally Posted by deadmancourt (Post 8114014)
lots of great feedback here...I CANT WAIT TO SEE WHAT DRIVER & ENGINE WIN THE WORLDS!:nod:....

Problem is that the winner can have the same results with a dozen different brands. Then everyone thinks that's the greatest engine.

deadmancourt 10-24-2010 12:16 AM


Originally Posted by hambone (Post 8114070)
Problem is that the winner can have the same results with a dozen different brands. Then everyone thinks that's the greatest engine.

ummm not me:weird: i am just curious:D

MAGPIE-121 10-24-2010 02:11 AM


Originally Posted by Werks (Post 8113591)
Lol, who ever mentioned anything about this poll being for company men to use for marketing purposes (other than you;) ). My only point was that I think that the results are slightly skewed because demographics, that is it. You will note that I was upfront enough to mention that the vast majority of our sales are in the US, so obviously from looking at our results I'm going to assume that the majority of the voters are US based. If it was based on global sales our percentage should in my oppinion be much lower. My saying that myself should show that im not being biased or dishonest about what im stating. As far as what is going on in the US I think that you are way off base but that again is my personal opinion and as they say opinions are just like (you know what) and we all got one lol. In any case please lets try to keep this friendly as I'm not trying to start another pointless debate about who's stuff may or may not be better or whos stuff is selling better etc etc. because at the end of the day it frankly does not really matter.

:( sorry mate, not trying to start anything, that's just the way the post looked to me as there was no mention that this poll was solely about the US market, which by the way is GOs boom market at the moment not AUS etc... that was wrongly stated ;):nod:
as long as we all get to smell nitro on the weekend life is good :weird::cool:

Jaz240 10-24-2010 09:07 AM


Originally Posted by Werks (Post 8114048)
True but STS or Caster :weird::confused::weird: Ain't gonna happen! :ha:

:lol: Only because no one would dare show up at the worlds with one. That would be like a player going to the superbowl with one of those leather helmets :D

Jomo918 10-24-2010 10:27 AM

:

Originally Posted by Jaz240 (Post 8114941)
:lol: Only because no one would dare show up at the worlds with one. That would be like a player going to the superbowl with one of those leather helmets :D

:lol::lol::lol::lol::lol::lol:

Werks 10-24-2010 10:55 AM


Originally Posted by Jaz240 (Post 8114941)
:lol: Only because no one would dare show up at the worlds with one. That would be like a player going to the superbowl with one of those leather helmets :D

Too true, however I still remember about 8 years ago or so when I believe it was STS was running some type of ad's about paying 10k contingency for making the A-main at the nats and Saxton went and did it lol! If I remember correctly though he was running a new engine every qualifier though, but he still did it! The same thing happened when we were testing in Pattaya. We were pitted off to the side and it seemed like every day there were a group of people breaking in engines right next to us. As you can imagine listening to that for 5 days gets a little old so I asked what was going on and found out that they were running new engines every other day lol! So I guess anything is possible at these type of events!

Werks 10-24-2010 10:59 AM


Originally Posted by MAGPIE-121 (Post 8114204)
:( sorry mate, not trying to start anything, that's just the way the post looked to me as there was no mention that this poll was solely about the US market, which by the way is GOs boom market at the moment not AUS etc... that was wrongly stated ;):nod:
as long as we all get to smell nitro on the weekend life is good :weird::cool:

No worries, i have no problem debating things with people. I actually edited my post because I did not want it to come across as too confrontational but as long as we can talk like adults and keep it shall we "say to the point" without getting upset, which you obviously can do I have no issues. I guess I'm just being a little hyper sensitive because of how things deteriorated on that thread last week lol! In any case we're all good :D:D:D

J.Whiting 10-24-2010 11:00 AM

come on guys please keep it down... this is a fun poll.... so far we have all been nice... so far!!! thank you...

juggaloracer198 10-27-2010 11:27 AM

HOSTILITY 101....geeezz

Stalkie 10-28-2010 04:41 AM

Might be good to see the results from the first poll compared to this one :tire: to be able to see what engine goes up and down on the list :nod: to get an idea of where people are heading. And then have it at regular intervals to see the progression:confused: Just a thought:)

The best bit is THEY ALL BURN NITRO:D:D

MAGPIE-121 10-28-2010 05:42 AM


Originally Posted by Stalkie (Post 8133360)
Might be good to see the results from the first poll compared to this one :tire: to be able to see what engine goes up and down on the list :nod: to get an idea of where people are heading. And then have it at regular intervals to see the progression:confused: Just a thought:)

The best bit is THEY ALL BURN NITRO:D:D

mmmm love the smell of the blue dot stalkie :weird:

teamlosi906 10-28-2010 05:52 AM

??
 
Where are the fox engines at :( They should be listed also.

MAGPIE-121 10-28-2010 05:57 AM


Originally Posted by teamlosi906 (Post 8133529)
Where are the fox engines at :( They should be listed also.

running from the hounds :lol::lol:

sorry, i couldn't help myself :rolleyes:

Roelof 10-30-2010 06:47 AM


Originally Posted by teamlosi906 (Post 8133529)
Where are the fox engines at :( They should be listed also.

That is just another Picco engine.....

I wonder why Sirio is not mentioned.


All times are GMT -7. It is currently 09:08 PM.

Powered By: vBulletin v3.9.3.9 Patch Level 3
Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.