Brushless combo question ?
#1
Thread Starter
Tech Initiate
Joined: Dec 2016
Posts: 28
Greetings .
I was wondering if this would be a direct replacement combo for my E-maxx # 39036-4 ?
Hobbywing Ezrun 5.5T/3650KV + eZRun-60A-SL combo for 1/10 & 1/12 Car $108.65 Free Shipping @GoodLuckBuy.com
My concerns are
1 The motor bolting to the stock plate
2 Will I still be able to use the 2 battery system
3 Are the motor shafts the same dia , ?
4 Will my (2 at a time) 5400 2s Venom batteries be OK to use .
Thanks for any help folks .
I was wondering if this would be a direct replacement combo for my E-maxx # 39036-4 ?
Hobbywing Ezrun 5.5T/3650KV + eZRun-60A-SL combo for 1/10 & 1/12 Car $108.65 Free Shipping @GoodLuckBuy.com
My concerns are
1 The motor bolting to the stock plate
2 Will I still be able to use the 2 battery system
3 Are the motor shafts the same dia , ?
4 Will my (2 at a time) 5400 2s Venom batteries be OK to use .
Thanks for any help folks .
Last edited by Digger 66; 04-29-2017 at 12:41 PM.
#2
Tech Regular
Joined: Aug 2016
Posts: 395
From: Sweden
I am sorry, but the e-maxx is too heavy for a 1/10 scale motor and esc. I would aim for a 2200kv motor and a 120A esc at least. I would also run with 4s lipos. There are several 1/8 scale systems out there from eg. hobbywing and other chinese brands.
#3
Joined: Apr 2009
Posts: 2,049
From: Long Island, NY
Traxxas may call the EMaxx a 1/10 but it's not the same 1/10 that the motor/esc manufacturer is thinking of when it says 1/10. A truck the weight of the EMaxx needs a 1/8 brushless system which consists of a motor that's at least 36mm diameter (40mm preferred) and at least 70mm long (74mm or longer preferred) with a kv that's 2400kv or less (2000-2200kv preferable). As far as esc it needs to be at least 120amp capable, 150amp preferred and 4s capable.
The system you linked is a 3650 motor (36mm diameter, 50mm long) which means less power and the motor working harder, heating up faster. The esc is only 60amp capable which will be exceeded in a truck this weight. With only 2s you have less voltage which means less power, higher amp draw, more heat etc.
There are some people using smaller motors and esc in an EMaxx with less than 4s. Those are usually Short Course Truck (SCT) systems and on 3s. SCT systems usually have 550 motors that aren't much smaller than 1/8 motors and the esc are usually at least 80amp if not 120amp. Even so with these SCT systems in an EMaxx you have to watch temps carefully and gear for slower speeds to keep them in check. If your truck has bigger and heavier tires, aluminum parts or if you run on grass then you need gear even slower. Get a 1/8 system you'll be better off.
The system you linked is a 3650 motor (36mm diameter, 50mm long) which means less power and the motor working harder, heating up faster. The esc is only 60amp capable which will be exceeded in a truck this weight. With only 2s you have less voltage which means less power, higher amp draw, more heat etc.
There are some people using smaller motors and esc in an EMaxx with less than 4s. Those are usually Short Course Truck (SCT) systems and on 3s. SCT systems usually have 550 motors that aren't much smaller than 1/8 motors and the esc are usually at least 80amp if not 120amp. Even so with these SCT systems in an EMaxx you have to watch temps carefully and gear for slower speeds to keep them in check. If your truck has bigger and heavier tires, aluminum parts or if you run on grass then you need gear even slower. Get a 1/8 system you'll be better off.
#5
Tech Regular
Joined: Aug 2016
Posts: 395
From: Sweden
Something like these:
Hobbywing MAX-8 150A 6S Sensorless ESC 4274 Brushless 2200KV Motor Combo Redcat | eBay
https://hobbyking.com/en_us/turnigy-...00kv-120a.html
Hobbywing QUICKRUN WP-8BL150 Brushless ESC w/4074 2000KV 4Pole Brushless Motor Combo w/Cardfor RC Cars $167.54 Free Shipping @GoodLuckBuy.com
There are many options for 1/8 scale motors and esc.
Hobbywing MAX-8 150A 6S Sensorless ESC 4274 Brushless 2200KV Motor Combo Redcat | eBay
https://hobbyking.com/en_us/turnigy-...00kv-120a.html
Hobbywing QUICKRUN WP-8BL150 Brushless ESC w/4074 2000KV 4Pole Brushless Motor Combo w/Cardfor RC Cars $167.54 Free Shipping @GoodLuckBuy.com
There are many options for 1/8 scale motors and esc.
#7
Joined: Apr 2009
Posts: 2,049
From: Long Island, NY
Edit: As far as recommendations for which esc and motor, I try to steer people away from Turnigy Trackstar. The Hobbywing Max8 Funniekid linked to is about $50 more but they are proven to be more reliable, the esc is 6s 150amp capable instead of 4s 120amp, the esc is smoother, according to the pics it already has 2 battery connectors setup in series, it's just a better system.
Last edited by Overdriven; 04-30-2017 at 05:30 PM.
#8
Thread Starter
Tech Initiate
Joined: Dec 2016
Posts: 28
Edit: As far as recommendations for which esc and motor, I try to steer people away from Turnigy Trackstar. The Hobbywing Max8 Funniekid linked to is about $50 more but they are proven to be more reliable, the esc is 6s 150amp capable instead of 4s 120amp, the esc is smoother, according to the pics it already has 2 battery connectors setup in series, it's just a better system.
Is it waterproof ?
If it doesn't come with a programmer , which one do I need ?? Or are they universal ?
#9
Joined: Apr 2009
Posts: 2,049
From: Long Island, NY
The Hobbywing Max8 is waterproof. I'm not sure you'll need a program card as the power switch has a "set" button used for programming at least some functions. Go to Hobbywing.com, look up the Max8 and it's instructions. The instructions will tell you what program card is compatible and what functions you can program without one and what functions you need a program card to change.



1Likes
