Com lathes
#1
Tech Fanatic
Thread Starter
Com lathes
I have been offered a brand new Hudy com lathe for £130 with a dimond tip it has only been used once as the guy brought it but is giving up racing. What are peoples opinions on the hudy lathes? I have heard all sorts of opinions from them been crap after a few cuts to been the best you can buy. Its not the automatic one!
Thanks for any help
Rick
Thanks for any help
Rick
#3
Tech Fanatic
Thread Starter
Thats just what some people said to me. Do you think its worth it then? Rick
#4
I like the Hudy products very much.. the only time I have heard of them going bad after a few cuts is with the standard bit (NOT THE DIAMOND) which is why it is very important to get a diamond bit from the start. Only thing I can say is get the lathe with the "V" guides and not the bearings... The bearings can shift durring a cut and the "V" guides only require a small dab of bushing oil to produce very high quality cuts.
Good luck with it!
F1-Fanatic
Good luck with it!
F1-Fanatic
Last edited by F1-Fanatic; 07-10-2002 at 04:06 PM.
#5
I have Tru Lathe 2 and a Fatom. The Trinity is a POS, the Fantom is great, though you have to play with it a bit to make it nice and smooth.
I have heard nothing but praise for Hudy products, I can't see why it would be a bad deal.
Go for it,
Josh
I have heard nothing but praise for Hudy products, I can't see why it would be a bad deal.
Go for it,
Josh
#6
Tech Champion
iTrader: (32)
Originally posted by F1-Fanatic
Only thing I can say is get the lathe with the "V" guides and not the bearings... The bearings can shift durring a cut and the "V" guides only require a small dab of bushing oil to produce very high quality cuts.
Good luck with it!
F1-Fanatic
Only thing I can say is get the lathe with the "V" guides and not the bearings... The bearings can shift durring a cut and the "V" guides only require a small dab of bushing oil to produce very high quality cuts.
Good luck with it!
F1-Fanatic
#7
Tech Elite
iTrader: (16)
The bearings wouldn't actually shift, but all ball bearings have a certain amount of play in them. If a piece of dust or dirt (like a tiny copper particle or several) gets inside the bearing race, it can cause the bearings to run slightly untrue, which can compromise the cut quality. A few ten-thousanths of an inch of runout in one of the bearings would be enough to reduce the cut quality. I'd try a thorough cleaning of the bearings, or even replace them, or better yet, swap them for a set of v-block supports.
It's also possible that a particles of copper right on the outer surfaces of the bearing could cause the armature shaft to "hop" over them as it spins, but I'd think a particle inside the bearing where you can't see it would be a more likely culprit.
Trips
It's also possible that a particles of copper right on the outer surfaces of the bearing could cause the armature shaft to "hop" over them as it spins, but I'd think a particle inside the bearing where you can't see it would be a more likely culprit.
Trips
#8
speedo, on your tru lathe 2 do u have play in the depth feed, because thats the problem that i had with mine,and i was getting horrible cuts every time, and it was pretty new, so i sent it to trinity and they sent me a new tru lathe 3 with v blocks and an extra set of ball bearings, and ive been able to get pretty decent cuts with it now. just thought id let u know cant guarantee trinity would send u a new lathe but they might be able to hewlp u out if it is fairly new. i still dont think the trinitys are as good as the hudys and cobras
#9
No, there is no play, and it does do decent cuts, just that for the money what you get is outrageus. First one I got was really messed up, all jerky etc, so they replaced that...
Much happier with the fantom though
Josh
Much happier with the fantom though
Josh
#10
Tech Champion
iTrader: (32)
Trips- How do you get the bearings out to do a little cleaning to them? I took a closer look at the bearings in the lathe and the set on the right side have a rusty ish looking color to them while the other set look like bearing should look. I'm thinking replacement for both sides but I really want to know if this is the problem. Bearings are cheap but if it does the same thing then it's a deeper issue that I have no clue as to how to go about fixing it.
#11
yai think id stick with the fantom too.
#12
Re: Com lathes
Originally posted by Rick Draper
I have been offered a brand new Hudy com lathe for £130 with a dimond tip it has only been used once as the guy brought it but is giving up racing. What are peoples opinions on the hudy lathes? I have heard all sorts of opinions from them been crap after a few cuts to been the best you can buy. Its not the automatic one!
Thanks for any help
Rick
I have been offered a brand new Hudy com lathe for £130 with a dimond tip it has only been used once as the guy brought it but is giving up racing. What are peoples opinions on the hudy lathes? I have heard all sorts of opinions from them been crap after a few cuts to been the best you can buy. Its not the automatic one!
Thanks for any help
Rick
#13
Hudy is definitely the "Mercedes" of lathes - well built and very solidly designed. Not sure how much 130 pounds is in dollars, but unless it's 2:1, that sounds like a killer deal.
I use a Cobra lathe - v-blocks on it and it works the best of any lathe I have used.
I had an original team Twister lathe and it was smooth and wonderful. The thing was 10 years old but worked like it was brand new. I was a dumba$$ and sold it. . .wish I had it back!
I had one Trinity lathe (built on the Twister patent) that used bearings rather than v-blocks. The play in the bearings is lateral play and it just didn't work as smooth as I wanted - also little bits of comm (that of course fly all over) tended to get down in there and make the bearings get kinda grindy. I spent a lot of time cleaning them. No problem with a V-block. . .
I use a Cobra lathe - v-blocks on it and it works the best of any lathe I have used.
I had an original team Twister lathe and it was smooth and wonderful. The thing was 10 years old but worked like it was brand new. I was a dumba$$ and sold it. . .wish I had it back!
I had one Trinity lathe (built on the Twister patent) that used bearings rather than v-blocks. The play in the bearings is lateral play and it just didn't work as smooth as I wanted - also little bits of comm (that of course fly all over) tended to get down in there and make the bearings get kinda grindy. I spent a lot of time cleaning them. No problem with a V-block. . .
#15
Tech Adept
If you check the prices on the Apex site you'll see the basic lathe is £129.95 plus £49.95 for the diamond tip so assuming the diamond is ok you're best part of £50 up. If however is got the bearing supports as well then they cost another £79.95 in which case its a good deal go for it. If not then its marginal depending on the tip condition unless you know where you can it re-dressed at a reasonable cost