1/12 forum
Naaahhhh the pan car manufacturers are not going to ruin
the handling traits of 1/12 by incorporating the use of traditional large size shorty
or whatever huge heavy 2s packs. They will just use the currently available 2s packs that are 1s sized. And the next battery war will be the increasing mah battle for supremacy in 1s sized 2s packs, currently in what the 3,000 mah range right? I bet they'd be doubled that in a year.
the handling traits of 1/12 by incorporating the use of traditional large size shorty
or whatever huge heavy 2s packs. They will just use the currently available 2s packs that are 1s sized. And the next battery war will be the increasing mah battle for supremacy in 1s sized 2s packs, currently in what the 3,000 mah range right? I bet they'd be doubled that in a year.
2s in 1s form factor are 6000mah as it is
Tech Master
iTrader: (52)
Joined: Oct 2008
Posts: 1,455
From: Spokane, WA
1) I never said I agree with it, someone just asked why it would make 1/12 more accessible.
2) I never mentioned cost, I just said it simplifies things, and it does. No booster/receiver pack is one less part to put on the car. You aren't going to attract new racers by telling them that they can use this speed control but need to add this or that to make it work. Simplicity is key when trying to attract new people.
3) Since you bring up cost... how often do we all buy a new spec motor anyway? Or new batteries? Most competitive spec racers buy the latest and greatest when it comes out. The cost argument is funny. Finish the season on the stuff we have now, buy new stuff for next season anyway. Just next season it's a 2s battery and a 21.5 or 25.5 or whatever motor, maybe a new speed control.
4) Have you tried a 2s in your car? I have, and I agree that 2s 17.5 is way too fast for spec. The F1 cars run 2s 25.5 and aren't too fast.
5) This is an IFMAR rule. ROAR hasn't changed their rules on this, so for the forseable future we are still on 1s.
2) I never mentioned cost, I just said it simplifies things, and it does. No booster/receiver pack is one less part to put on the car. You aren't going to attract new racers by telling them that they can use this speed control but need to add this or that to make it work. Simplicity is key when trying to attract new people.
3) Since you bring up cost... how often do we all buy a new spec motor anyway? Or new batteries? Most competitive spec racers buy the latest and greatest when it comes out. The cost argument is funny. Finish the season on the stuff we have now, buy new stuff for next season anyway. Just next season it's a 2s battery and a 21.5 or 25.5 or whatever motor, maybe a new speed control.
4) Have you tried a 2s in your car? I have, and I agree that 2s 17.5 is way too fast for spec. The F1 cars run 2s 25.5 and aren't too fast.
5) This is an IFMAR rule. ROAR hasn't changed their rules on this, so for the forseable future we are still on 1s.
As strictly a local-level club racer (people like me make up the majority of the "competitive" hobbyist - not the guys competing on a regional, national or international level with partial or full sponsorship) I have personally used the same ESC for the past four years, the same 17.5 motor for the past two years and the same battery pack for the past two years. I just spent $40 on a new 1s SMC pack as my old one was puffing so badly that it was difficult to fit under the center shock on my XTi WC. I would say this behavior is normal at my track for the class of 15 or so racers we have in 1/12th scale. Many guys are using cars that are 4-5 years old as well.
I have not tried a 2s in my 1/12th scale. Correct me if I'm wrong, but isn't F1 failing miserably as a class? Didn't they move F1 from 21.5 to 25.5? What are lap times and cornering speeds of 2s 25.5 F1 like compared to 1s 17.5 1/12th scale? Let's also look at touring car. What are lap times and cornering speeds like for 17.5 2s touring car compared to 1/12th scale? Stock 1/12th scale is still faster right? And yet you have classes like VTA and USGT slowing the touring cars down with 21.5 and 25.5 motors and non-optimal tires and these classes seem to be doing very well in this country, attracting guys that wouldn't otherwise run touring cars because of the speeds... Speeds which are already slower than 1s 17.5 1/12th scale to begin with. And now we might be interested in speeding up the entry level 1/12th scale class by making it 2s.
I get that ROAR hasn't jumped on board yet, but it sounds like the rest of the World is and it's silly to think we won't be far behind.
Tech Adept
iTrader: (6)
Joined: Jul 2011
Posts: 174
From: Myrtle Beach SC
Personally I feel it's more that the esc and or battery manufacturer don't want to make 1cell esc's or 1cell batteries. I doubt they have the sells or profit to warrant them. If they can get everyone on 2cell then there profits go up.
1s & 2s lipo Form factors are the same, contents same, only assembled differently
Any ESC works, with a $5 adaptor, cheaper than aftermarket capacitors that are all the rage...
Based off of the times at IIC from A main to A main. It's fairly close with the edge going to TC by about .2 a lap. On a pretty good size track.
Tech Adept
iTrader: (6)
Joined: Jul 2011
Posts: 174
From: Myrtle Beach SC
I'm just looking at the 1cell stuff being a nitch market as is. Most hobby shops carry 2cell stuff. Not to say they don't have 1cell stuff but I'm sure it doesn't move as fast. And for the manufacturers if they aren't selling the volume of 1cell stuff as they do 2cell stuff the profit margins will be low. Most companies have to look at that to stay viable. Which is why you don't see every manufacturer making 2cell esc or even multiple 1cell esc.
Tech Adept
iTrader: (6)
Joined: Jul 2011
Posts: 174
From: Myrtle Beach SC
Even look at what legitimate companies make 1cell boosters. I know you can get cheap hobbykings ones or ones made by a local. But hobbywing is the only company mass producing them and they make a 1cell esc. If the market for 1cell stuff was great enough every company would be making 1cell stuff.
But pls don't take my comments as I like the decision. I feel it will hurt more than help in the shirt term. Long term who knows
But pls don't take my comments as I like the decision. I feel it will hurt more than help in the shirt term. Long term who knows
Tech Master
iTrader: (52)
Joined: Oct 2008
Posts: 1,455
From: Spokane, WA
By the way, this is the track I race at. How do you think 2s 17.5 would fare here
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dvs2J9YOHaQ
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qMkxv-gyQm4

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dvs2J9YOHaQ
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qMkxv-gyQm4
Even look at what legitimate companies make 1cell boosters. I know you can get cheap hobbykings ones or ones made by a local. But hobbywing is the only company mass producing them and they make a 1cell esc. If the market for 1cell stuff was great enough every company would be making 1cell stuff.
But pls don't take my comments as I like the decision. I feel it will hurt more than help in the shirt term. Long term who knows
But pls don't take my comments as I like the decision. I feel it will hurt more than help in the shirt term. Long term who knows
It wasn't that long ago (before 1s) that very few companies sold 1/12 kits
Now, nearly every mfg is in the game, and plenty of new companies formed on pan cars alone
Should be enough in this niche market for some/many to profit from
Tech Master
iTrader: (52)
Joined: Oct 2008
Posts: 1,455
From: Spokane, WA
F1 went from 21.5 to 25.5
WGT has waned in favor of WGTR
VTA and USGT are doing well and are for all intents and purposes just slower touring car classes.
We are talking about a change to 1/12th scale that really doesn't simplify anything and has the potential to speed the class up, which is the opposite direction other classes are moving to get participation up.
Tech Addict
iTrader: (5)
Joined: Jul 2013
Posts: 714
From: Brisbane
I've tried one of these $5 boosters and almost destroyed a brand new WGT as it made the car uncontrollable. I put in an RX pack and the problem went away. The least I would use is a Hopbbywing model at about $20. The one used at the Worlds is sold by Trinity for $50!
Personally, I think a change to 2S could be a boost for areas/countries where 1/12 is not really popular at the moment. But the change will be a big pain in the butt for places where 1S 1/12 is doing well. I'm reluctantly getting back into 1/12 because I love the cars and the way they drive. But I'd be diving in happily if it was 2S as I'd be able to share batteries with my F1 car and have a wider range of ESCs to choose from.
Personally, I think a change to 2S could be a boost for areas/countries where 1/12 is not really popular at the moment. But the change will be a big pain in the butt for places where 1S 1/12 is doing well. I'm reluctantly getting back into 1/12 because I love the cars and the way they drive. But I'd be diving in happily if it was 2S as I'd be able to share batteries with my F1 car and have a wider range of ESCs to choose from.



2991Likes