R/C Tech Forums

R/C Tech Forums (https://www.rctech.net/forum/)
-   Electric On-Road (https://www.rctech.net/forum/electric-road-2/)
-   -   1/12 forum (https://www.rctech.net/forum/electric-road/37-1-12-forum.html)

theisgroup 10-07-2009 03:30 PM

be aware that even .2sec a lap difference for 40 laps, that is 8 sec. that is probably close to a lap difference

GasGod 10-07-2009 03:40 PM

I really wanna see saddle pack lipos--any backyard "engeniering"been done .
like on some helio packs wired in parallel to get the Mah up?

slotracer577 10-07-2009 04:30 PM

On the oval track I run the 17.5 4 cell and 13.5 1cell are pretty equal. The 27T is a little slower probably .3 to .4. Might not be fair as the 27T are usually slower drivers.




Originally Posted by RAL (Post 6442524)
I know at our local carpet track these are your options for "stock" all combo's are looked at as equal. Don't know if it really is. I'm sure the gurus on here can tell you. I'm curious as well as to how they match up.

27t 4cell
17.5 4cell
13.5 1s lipo


CypressMidWest 10-07-2009 05:21 PM


Originally Posted by kn7671 (Post 6437526)
Just better! :lol:

If by better, you mean uglier and heavier wheel, with the same rubber, then you're right.

Old Tech 10-08-2009 08:30 AM


Originally Posted by GasGod (Post 6442988)
I really wanna see saddle pack lipos--any backyard "engeniering"been done .
like on some helio packs wired in parallel to get the Mah up?

Speedzone is working on one. Some discussion about the pack here:

http://www.rctech.net/forum/electric...00mah-30c.html

ammdrew 10-08-2009 08:38 AM

13.5 3.7v does the same laptimes as 13.5 4 cell. So no it is not equal to 17.5 4 cell.... The bigger part of the picture is the corner speed vrs straight speed. Laptimes for 3.7v with the 10% drop in wt gain all the hp loss back in corner speed and run the same laptimes but in a rd course environent it makes for a messy race as if you have similar skilled drivers the flow lines are different through corners and into the straights.

RBMike 10-08-2009 09:53 AM

Anyone know where I can find a 17.5 Duo2 "in stock"? Seems to be on back-order eveywhere.

Scottrik 10-08-2009 10:16 AM


Originally Posted by ammdrew (Post 6446191)
13.5 3.7v does the same laptimes as 13.5 4 cell. So no it is not equal to 17.5 4 cell....

Testing here showed that with the same gearing a 1s / 13.5 was VERY close to the same as a 4-cell / 17.5. But when we started gearing the 1s / 13.5 up to where it was optimized it was significantly faster than the 4-cell / 17.5 is.

I know the W. Washington guys (Bodine, DuTemple, et al) have decided that 1s / 13.5 and 4-cell 13.5 run together acceptably well. The Fantasy World Summer Sizzler (25th Annual!!) allowed either of these specs and the main proved to be a duel between Mike with a 4-cell car vs. Brian with a 1s car. Bodine made a small mistake early and spent 6 minutes running several seconds behind but the gap was pretty much the same throughout. With 1 minute to go the 4-cell car began to slow noticeably (geared pretty aggressively to keep ahead of the BodineMachine) to near full dump at the end where he won by a second or so. Had the race been even one more lap (heck...one more corner) and Brian would have had him.

mkdut 10-08-2009 11:01 AM

[QUOTE=Scottrik;6446629]

Originally Posted by ammdrew (Post 6446191)
13.5 3.7v does the same laptimes as 13.5 4 cell. So no it is not equal to 17.5 4 cell....QUOTE]

Testing here showed that with the same gearing a 1s / 13.5 was VERY close to the same as a 4-cell / 17.5. But when we started gearing the 1s / 13.5 up to where it was optimized it was significantly faster than the 4-cell / 17.5 is.

I know the W. Washington guys (Bodine, DuTemple, et al) have decided that 1s / 13.5 and 4-cell 13.5 run together acceptably well. The Fantasy World Summer Sizzler (25th Annual!!) allowed either of these specs and the main proved to be a duel between Mike with a 4-cell car vs. Brian with a 1s car. Bodine made a small mistake early and spent 6 minutes running several seconds behind but the gap was pretty much the same throughout. With 1 minute to go the 4-cell car began to slow noticeably (geared pretty aggressively to keep ahead of the BodineMachine) to near full dump at the end where he won by a second or so. Had the race been even one more lap (heck...one more corner) and Brian would have had him.

Without a doubt we have proven that they are fairly equal. The 4 cell had more speed down the straight but the 1S with the light weight floats through the infield. You could really tell the weight difference between the two when getting into the corners. It seemed like I was trying to stop a dump truck compared to Brian's car.

And yes Brian would have needed one more corner. My 9 month old cells had had enough.

avs 10-09-2009 07:55 AM


Originally Posted by AdrianM (Post 4094783)
Please copy and paste this into MS Word so you have saved locally:)

Building a Diff

I use plain chrome steel diff balls from BMI, IRS, anyone...they are all the same high grade 1/8" ball bearings.

I like to use Schumacher U1301 silicon diff grease or Associated silicon diff grease, the thick type in a plastic cup not the stealth grease in a squeeze tube. Stealth grease is too thin and gets flung out too easy.

The diff balls I buy come in a 100 pack for ~$8. I open the pack over a clean paper tower and dump them out. All diff balls have a coating of oil on them to protect them while they sit on a shelf. I use motor spray carefull to wet them and then roll them on the paper towel to dry them. I then dump them all into the cup of diff grease. I keep them there untill I use them.

When I build a diff I sand both sides of the diff rings with 600 grit wet-dry sandpaper lubricated with a little motor spray untill I see an even finish across the face of the rings. I then clean the rings with motor spray and dry them on a clean paper tower.

Be sure to clean your finger tips with motor spray before touching the diff balls or rings. If you get any bearing oil or traction compound on them from your fingers it will contaminate the diff and mess it up.

I then pluck the diff balls out of the diff grease cup with a small clean flat blade screwdriver and put them in the spur gear. They will carry all the diff grease they need with them. You do not need to put more on the rings. I put a ball in all 12 holes in the outer circle. The inner circle of holes is for the no longer used small diameter "Stealth" diff rings.

Assemble the diff normally but tighten it slowly until you just start to get diff action. If you overtighten it you can dimple the rings and flat spot the balls. Tighten it and check the gear for slipping. As soon as the gear starts to get hard to slip stop.

Mount some tires on the axle. Hold one tire and the gear locked and force the opposide side to turn a few turns. Repeat with the other side. This is called cutting the diff. Cutting the diff smooths out any imperfections in the rings and balls by burnishing them. The diff may have loosened a little from cutting it so readjust it so the gear is very hard to slip (this is tighter than the previous step).

Install a motor and put the car up so the wheel are not touching the table. Run it at meduim throttle and alternatly touch one tire then the other untill it just stops then let go. This will heat up and fling out excess diff grease as well as breaking in the diff. Do this a couple times per side.

Re adjust the diff a final time so it wil not slip and you are done. The diff should be glass smooth. It should spin very freely as if it were really loose but the diff gear should be almost impossible to slip.

If the diff is gritty with new rings and balls replace the outer right side hub bearing.

If the diff is slipping you have some petroleum oil contamination in the diff. Take everything apart and start over after cleaing everything with motor spray.

Some people were having diff troubles last night. Because I found your guidance very helpful, (and the search feature has been goofy) i just relisted it here again.

inconceivable 10-09-2009 09:04 AM

Thank you for re-posting this !

Slapmaster6000 10-09-2009 09:46 AM


Originally Posted by Scottrik (Post 6446629)
Testing here showed that with the same gearing a 1s / 13.5 was VERY close to the same as a 4-cell / 17.5. But when we started gearing the 1s / 13.5 up to where it was optimized it was significantly faster than the 4-cell / 17.5 is.

I know the W. Washington guys (Bodine, DuTemple, et al) have decided that 1s / 13.5 and 4-cell 13.5 run together acceptably well. The Fantasy World Summer Sizzler (25th Annual!!) allowed either of these specs and the main proved to be a duel between Mike with a 4-cell car vs. Brian with a 1s car. Bodine made a small mistake early and spent 6 minutes running several seconds behind but the gap was pretty much the same throughout. With 1 minute to go the 4-cell car began to slow noticeably (geared pretty aggressively to keep ahead of the BodineMachine) to near full dump at the end where he won by a second or so. Had the race been even one more lap (heck...one more corner) and Brian would have had him.

I would like to point out this was on asphalt out doors on a 80x 120'ish medium turn type track. Take this scenario to a 40x90 carpet track and I feel that you will see the 4 cell car has a .2ths advantage. Moral to the story is; even with weight allowances, I don't think that you will achieve a true evenness between 4 cell & 1S.

I can say that for those that are holding onto their 4 cells..... let 'em go! The 1S pack is the brushless motor of batteries. It's true that we are giving up on the best cells that we have had since the Sanyo 2000's, but get over it. You will be happier for it.

Brian

mkdut 10-09-2009 09:55 AM


Originally Posted by Slapmaster6000 (Post 6451320)
I would like to point out this was on asphalt out doors on a 80x 120'ish medium turn type track. Take this scenario to a 40x90 carpet track and I feel that you will see the 4 cell car has a .2ths advantage. Moral to the story is; even with weight allowances, I don't think that you will achieve a true evenness between 4 cell & 1S.

I can say that for those that are holding onto their 4 cells..... let 'em go! The 1S pack is the brushless motor of batteries. It's true that we are giving up on the best cells that we have had since the Sanyo 2000's, but get over it. You will be happier for it.

Brian

Anytime I can pick up 2 tenths on you I am happy. Makes for some pretty equal racing.

Scottrik 10-09-2009 03:10 PM


Originally Posted by mkdut (Post 6451351)
Anytime I can pick up 2 tenths on you I am happy. Makes for some pretty equal racing.

I need 20 tenths to make it close... :cry:

Slapmaster6000 10-09-2009 05:54 PM

3 cell nimh vs 1S???
 
20 tenths :lol: Next you'll be asking for 2 seconds! :D


You know, just for conversation..... has anyone tried 3 cell nimh against the 1S format with equal running weight? I know that you would have to go through all the booster/rx pack stuff for the 3 cell car, but would it ease the transition of the nimh guys into 1S and keep a club from splitting up the 12th scale classes?

Let's just suppose there is a club the runs about a dozen 12th scale cars, some are moving over to 1S while the others are left behind due the economy or what ever. I would guess that you could have the 4 cell guys drop a cell and have the new minimum weight be something like 800g for everyone. Sure, there will be some weight balancing to do in the chassis, but could it work? Will chargers correctly peak off 3 cells? The idea is.... a 4 cell guy would have just a few more race packs. And when the time comes, the switch over to 1S wouldn't be drastically different to the equipment once the budget allows it.


All times are GMT -7. It is currently 02:49 AM.

Powered By: vBulletin v3.9.3.9 Patch Level 3
Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.