R/C Tech Forums

R/C Tech Forums (https://www.rctech.net/forum/)
-   Electric Off-Road (https://www.rctech.net/forum/electric-off-road-4/)
-   -   hobbywing v3 vs orion r10 (https://www.rctech.net/forum/electric-off-road/672776-hobbywing-v3-vs-orion-r10.html)

vr6cj 02-01-2013 10:15 PM


Originally Posted by ridgeracer (Post 11761090)
Anyone know why Jorn Neumann are still using the old Speed Passion esc and not the new pro ?
That makes me think ..

Yeah, fitment for his sedan. They answered this in the SP thread. Guess the new Reventon pro's square shape didnt fit in his sedan. He needed the long rectangle type esc. Simple as that.

The REv Pros are awesome. Super smooth. Lots of power and easy to use/program. I've had problems with them at the start but they are just to good for me to switch to another esc. The price is cheap too.

Jason Turner 02-01-2013 10:29 PM

This guy pretty much nailed it. I love the no switch part & the cap isn't in a huge plastic case so it's easier to find space for it. And if your into boost/timing there is a ton of extra features there the Orion doesn't have. And as far as feeling I can't tell the difference between the two on the track.

And I heard Orion's is more like a V2.5 and rated higher than it actually is (like 90C batts)


Originally Posted by ben73 (Post 11761435)
I have had the R10 pro and its great.

I got the V3.1 and its even better.

Its a smaller footprint, looks better (case it full aluminium in black), it has no switch to mount (as its onboard the esc) and the software is amazing.

You can turn the car off by holding full brake for 7 seconds. awesome feature at the end of a race.

And the software is fantastic. You can adjust both punch and brake and have different profiles come in at 50% of throttle etc...

Its a step ahead of the R10 pro


8ight-e 02-01-2013 11:21 PM


Originally Posted by JPKinsella (Post 11761166)
I have bolth and bolth are very good but I would give the orion the slight advantage.. Why.. for one the orion has better brakes smoother or more lineir and stronger weather or not that has to do with the caps or not don't know.. also the orion is a 160amp vs the HW is a 120amp I do run a R10pro on a 4pole 4600 in a STCE wouldn't try it with a HW.. Oh yeah my local hobby shop stocks R10pro for 199.99$$ Have not found the HW for less that 209.99$$.. Horizon is actually good with customer service on these and motors Its Lipos that is almost impossible for them to warrenty..

I've got 2.5 race seasons on a hw v3, lol SCTE w/ 4 pole xerun 4k. I would try it all day long every day, ohh wait I do :) PS v3's are only 160ish now. The hw lcd program box gives it a one up and is cheaper for a 2up. Falcon is great w/ customer service, and to be honest you won't have to send it in unless you do something that would toast any esc.

++ to the others.. the v3 button power button is awesome, new v3.1 looks great those are on ebay for 190, not sure if faclons stock is v3 or 3.1

ridgeracer 02-02-2013 12:16 AM


Originally Posted by vr6cj (Post 11762135)
Yeah, fitment for his sedan. They answered this in the SP thread. Guess the new Reventon pro's square shape didnt fit in his sedan. He needed the long rectangle type esc. Simple as that.

The REv Pros are awesome. Super smooth. Lots of power and easy to use/program. I've had problems with them at the start but they are just to good for me to switch to another esc. The price is cheap too.

He also went back to the old SP esc in the DEX210

RC*PHREAK 02-03-2013 10:18 AM


Originally Posted by 8ight-e (Post 11762250)
I've got 2.5 race seasons on a hw v3, lol SCTE w/ 4 pole xerun 4k. I would try it all day long every day, ohh wait I do :) PS v3's are only 160ish now. The hw lcd program box gives it a one up and is cheaper for a 2up. Falcon is great w/ customer service, and to be honest you won't have to send it in unless you do something that would toast any esc.

++ to the others.. the v3 button power button is awesome, new v3.1 looks great those are on ebay for 190, not sure if faclons stock is v3 or 3.1

i've got about 12 packs through my heavy pig tekno SCT410 with the V3/4000kv 4 pole combo. after 8 minutes or so of hard running the esc comes off at 100 degrees (motor about 120).

TRG 03-24-2013 08:02 AM

Program Box
 

Originally Posted by ovalracer1m (Post 11364004)
hard to say, I have run both the R10 and a number of hobbywings and both have performed almost identical on the track as least as far as i could tell/feel. I wouldnt say the orion software is any better. The new V3 has a few nice features the R10 does not. Also, the program box is a 1/3 of the price for the HW vs the re-labeled Orion version.

If the Orion Program box is just a re-labeled HW. Do you know if you can use the HW box to program the Orion esc ??????

Woulvesbaine 05-13-2013 01:00 PM

Necroing this thread. Does anyone know if the HW program box and Orion program box can be used with the other brand?

I have one Orion, which I really like, so if I need a new esc, I was thinking HW v3.1. Already have the Orion program box.

Badger5 05-13-2013 02:03 PM


Originally Posted by Woulvesbaine (Post 12147661)
Necroing this thread. Does anyone know if the HW program box and Orion program box can be used with the other brand?

I have one Orion, which I really like, so if I need a new esc, I was thinking HW v3.1. Already have the Orion program box.

With the original Orion software for the set up box you could use either but there were issues with it, the software was updated and this also removed the possibility of using the Orion program box on HW or SP ESC's.

Woulvesbaine 09-25-2013 10:38 AM


Originally Posted by Badger5 (Post 12147881)
With the original Orion software for the set up box you could use either but there were issues with it, the software was updated and this also removed the possibility of using the Orion program box on HW or SP ESC's.

Thanks. I have so many different ESCs at this point I'd like to eventually consolidate to all HW. The Tekins are great, so well, realistically, maybe consolidate to two brands. lol.

randy0025 10-25-2013 05:44 AM


Originally Posted by ovalracer1m (Post 11364195)
Have you had to deal with getting an orion product warrantied through Horizon? It is terrible. Almost as bad as HW, which luckily i have never had a issue with. You can get a HW with the program box for the same cost you can buy a 160A R10 with there re-branded box. Either way, its close on price and both are great esc's.

That is 100% not true. Horizon has already sent me 1 r10 pro and 1 r8 pro and took 5 days. i Sent in my old and they sent brand new. like any company they mite have been behind but Ill stick by horizon support any day

8ight-e 10-25-2013 05:52 AM


Originally Posted by randy0025 (Post 12664658)
That is 100% not true. Horizon has already sent me 1 r10 pro and 1 r8 pro and took 5 days. i Sent in my old and they sent brand new. like any company they mite have been behind but Ill stick by horizon support any day

I've had no issues dealing with falcon's support; granted I don't have nearly as many issues with my hobbywing stuff as I did with 'other' brands :P

I highly recommend the new v3.1 stock esc too; awesome esc for any 2wd vehicle and even can use in a 4x4 buggy. I'd still opt for the 120a version for 4x4 sct though; those hobbywing xerun 4k motors are just retard awesome, still no better motor iMO.


All times are GMT -7. It is currently 05:06 AM.

Powered By: vBulletin v3.9.3.8
Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.