Caslte Creation Mamba Max VS Novak GTB system
#31
Tech Elite
iTrader: (13)
The key to remember is that is depends on the track you are running on.
This past winter I started with a 5700 in my 2wd and actually went to a 4600 and turned better lap times. I ran a 5700 in my 4wd.
For a brushed comparsion I thought the 5700 felt simalar to an 11 turn and the 4600 felt similar to a 13 turn.
This past winter I started with a 5700 in my 2wd and actually went to a 4600 and turned better lap times. I ran a 5700 in my 4wd.
For a brushed comparsion I thought the 5700 felt simalar to an 11 turn and the 4600 felt similar to a 13 turn.
#33
Tech Lord
iTrader: (22)
I ran the Mamba max last season and canned it for the Novak. I have a lot of experience with Novak and its all good.
The reason I canned it was due to the abrupt bottom end take off. Any hoot a few weeks ago I ran a Mamba max with the new updated program and I tell ya it was like running a Novak. I'm going to run the Mamba sidewinder 4600 in our B-4 and have yet to decide whether to run one in our T-4.? This summer will tell me what to run in the truck this winter. We are going to try to kill this side winder out side this year. Mamba does not make any thing slow so be ready to GO FAST AND TRY NOT TO CRASH.!
Mamba attribute. You can run a Mamba hot enough to light a cigarette. It will handle more watts this Mamber Jamber will put the fire to your motor no Shiot!, and they have got the program right this time. I always said if they get the program right Novak is in trouble.
Good points.
The biggest reason its so likable...........Low profile with a reasonable foot print and will fit under any buggy body, no need for a fan, sensor less, and who could cry about the price other than the guy who pays 275.00 for a Novak system. MAKE"M CRY! And they have a great support system and warranty system.
Down side to the Mamba some rules don't allow them from what I've heard.?
Don't quote me there.
But the only thing and I mean only thing I don't like is taking my computer to a dirt track. The time I did i had ants and dust from all angles. But the programming is sweet as it gets and more precise. So its a love hate. I will just do programs from the car.
In short you just cant go wrong either way but look at the price. Yikes! Mamba has got to be working the shipping Dept. over time.
The reason I canned it was due to the abrupt bottom end take off. Any hoot a few weeks ago I ran a Mamba max with the new updated program and I tell ya it was like running a Novak. I'm going to run the Mamba sidewinder 4600 in our B-4 and have yet to decide whether to run one in our T-4.? This summer will tell me what to run in the truck this winter. We are going to try to kill this side winder out side this year. Mamba does not make any thing slow so be ready to GO FAST AND TRY NOT TO CRASH.!
Mamba attribute. You can run a Mamba hot enough to light a cigarette. It will handle more watts this Mamber Jamber will put the fire to your motor no Shiot!, and they have got the program right this time. I always said if they get the program right Novak is in trouble.
Good points.
The biggest reason its so likable...........Low profile with a reasonable foot print and will fit under any buggy body, no need for a fan, sensor less, and who could cry about the price other than the guy who pays 275.00 for a Novak system. MAKE"M CRY! And they have a great support system and warranty system.
Down side to the Mamba some rules don't allow them from what I've heard.?
Don't quote me there.
But the only thing and I mean only thing I don't like is taking my computer to a dirt track. The time I did i had ants and dust from all angles. But the programming is sweet as it gets and more precise. So its a love hate. I will just do programs from the car.
In short you just cant go wrong either way but look at the price. Yikes! Mamba has got to be working the shipping Dept. over time.
#35
Tech Champion
iTrader: (159)
Unfortunately, you can't open up the mamba motors easily...I had one and slowly over time sand/dirt found their way through the extra mounting holes and there was nothing I could do when it started scraping internally. Some crazy good locktite is used on the small screws and all I managed to to was mangle them
In threads gone by castle has explicitly noted the motors aren't meant to be taken apart...
In threads gone by castle has explicitly noted the motors aren't meant to be taken apart...
#36
something to keep in mind. you can do a good job of configuring the ESC without a laptop too. Its pretty straight forward.
I think both ESCs are great, I like the footprint of the Novak, but like the Mamba max as you can configure on a laptop if you want, and it doesn't need a fan.
Thing to keep in mind if you have a T4 (I have one in a T4) you need to trim the side wall a bit so you can access the port on the mamba max.
the sidewinder (there cheaper version) I believe can also mate with a pc too.
max I would recommend motorwise is a 5700 for a truck.
I think both ESCs are great, I like the footprint of the Novak, but like the Mamba max as you can configure on a laptop if you want, and it doesn't need a fan.
Thing to keep in mind if you have a T4 (I have one in a T4) you need to trim the side wall a bit so you can access the port on the mamba max.
the sidewinder (there cheaper version) I believe can also mate with a pc too.
max I would recommend motorwise is a 5700 for a truck.
Cain:
How much time on the average do you get with running 4900 mah battery? What gear are running on the motor?
Thanks...
#37
Tech Legend
iTrader: (51)
Join Date: Sep 2001
Location: Castle Mamba Max Pro. Feel its power!!!!!!!!!!
Posts: 21,220
Trader Rating: 51 (100%+)
I ran the Mamba max last season and canned it for the Novak. I have a lot of experience with Novak and its all good.
The reason I canned it was due to the abrupt bottom end take off. Any hoot a few weeks ago I ran a Mamba max with the new updated program and I tell ya it was like running a Novak. I'm going to run the Mamba sidewinder 4600 in our B-4 and have yet to decide whether to run one in our T-4.? This summer will tell me what to run in the truck this winter. We are going to try to kill this side winder out side this year. Mamba does not make any thing slow so be ready to GO FAST AND TRY NOT TO CRASH.!
Mamba attribute. You can run a Mamba hot enough to light a cigarette. It will handle more watts this Mamber Jamber will put the fire to your motor no Shiot!, and they have got the program right this time. I always said if they get the program right Novak is in trouble.
Good points.
The biggest reason its so likable...........Low profile with a reasonable foot print and will fit under any buggy body, no need for a fan, sensor less, and who could cry about the price other than the guy who pays 275.00 for a Novak system. MAKE"M CRY! And they have a great support system and warranty system.
Down side to the Mamba some rules don't allow them from what I've heard.?
Don't quote me there.
But the only thing and I mean only thing I don't like is taking my computer to a dirt track. The time I did i had ants and dust from all angles. But the programming is sweet as it gets and more precise. So its a love hate. I will just do programs from the car.
In short you just cant go wrong either way but look at the price. Yikes! Mamba has got to be working the shipping Dept. over time.
The reason I canned it was due to the abrupt bottom end take off. Any hoot a few weeks ago I ran a Mamba max with the new updated program and I tell ya it was like running a Novak. I'm going to run the Mamba sidewinder 4600 in our B-4 and have yet to decide whether to run one in our T-4.? This summer will tell me what to run in the truck this winter. We are going to try to kill this side winder out side this year. Mamba does not make any thing slow so be ready to GO FAST AND TRY NOT TO CRASH.!
Mamba attribute. You can run a Mamba hot enough to light a cigarette. It will handle more watts this Mamber Jamber will put the fire to your motor no Shiot!, and they have got the program right this time. I always said if they get the program right Novak is in trouble.
Good points.
The biggest reason its so likable...........Low profile with a reasonable foot print and will fit under any buggy body, no need for a fan, sensor less, and who could cry about the price other than the guy who pays 275.00 for a Novak system. MAKE"M CRY! And they have a great support system and warranty system.
Down side to the Mamba some rules don't allow them from what I've heard.?
Don't quote me there.
But the only thing and I mean only thing I don't like is taking my computer to a dirt track. The time I did i had ants and dust from all angles. But the programming is sweet as it gets and more precise. So its a love hate. I will just do programs from the car.
In short you just cant go wrong either way but look at the price. Yikes! Mamba has got to be working the shipping Dept. over time.
If you race at some ROAR events the motors may not be legal but for me I could care less about ROAR as I'm not going to any of the races they put on and in offroad at least where I race at its all mod so the tracks allow any hard cased lipo and any brand brushless.
Rules are alot more picky in touring car and again in are area are always changing where the offroad rules are very simple and allow everyone to run.
#41
So, people have pretty much told you the $135 system and the $250 systems are equal. You do the math.
#42
Tech Adept
Might want to be careful about getting the checkpoint lipo. I think its 16C continuous. Personally I use the trakpower 4900 mah lipos cuz they are 20C continuous. I never tried the checkpoints but I was told there is a noticable difference. You should get more runtime but you might not be running the full potential of your brushless system. Also, I have a friend who runs a 5700 kV motor and I run a 6900 kV motor and he probably gets around 18-20 minutes of runtime. I would say I average 12-15 minutes. He also has greater low end punch than I do which is more idea for the tight tracks we run at. Are there even 20 minute electric mains?? I thought those were all nitro races.
#43
Might want to be careful about getting the checkpoint lipo. I think its 16C continuous. Personally I use the trakpower 4900 mah lipos cuz they are 20C continuous. I never tried the checkpoints but I was told there is a noticable difference. You should get more runtime but you might not be running the full potential of your brushless system. Also, I have a friend who runs a 5700 kV motor and I run a 6900 kV motor and he probably gets around 18-20 minutes of runtime. I would say I average 12-15 minutes. He also has greater low end punch than I do which is more idea for the tight tracks we run at. Are there even 20 minute electric mains?? I thought those were all nitro races.
Thanks...
#44
Tech Regular
well, the $130 system needs the $20 cable if you don't have one already
you need that cable to be able to upload the latest software to the sidewinder, at least the early ones weren't shipping with the latest "smooth" 1.17 software
#45
Tech Adept
Checkpoints are actually made by trakpower but for some reason they are only spec'd at 16C. I can only guess they have a higher mah rating and lower c rating because they are the same size as the trakpowers. I guess that is the whole give and take thing. They (checkpoints) should give you at least 20 minutes of runtime with the 5700 kV motor. The 4600 kV motor should give you well over 20 minutes with the trakpowers. Maxamps probably makes a higher mah rated lipo but I dont know if they would fit without any modifications. I normally run 5 minute mains so I dont worry much about overall runtime which is why I like the trakpowers.