SNW107A54512A vs XPTPI-3431 for throttle.

Using Futaba pls . Trying to pick out of the 2 and was looking for opinions if used them or heard about it.

Was looking at Savox 1252 but some mixed reviews so those 2 caught my eye above.

Ok thinking the same. Going in drag race concept promod basically 1/10 I guess

Actually the Xpert goes up to 6.6 but still the 7.4 does sound better

No I did not choose those bcof the weight trying to get the lightest but good specs is why I chosed them.

Thanks just checked out specs not bad at all. I think it would be nice just for throttle is what I Need

Something sanwa does different that you may want to consider.

positive-the servo is programmable. In the world of servo control you send a command to the servo from the receiver. The servo interprets the command and tells the motor to move at a rate. The servo then compares the pot position to the commanded position and if it came up short or long as compared to what it internally predicted it compensates again to match the pot to the command. For example if it was on steering and the torque of the wheels was too much for the servo to make position it will internally add more command to get the commanded to match the actual position. Most servos do this. The sanwa is programable so you can tell it to hit the motor harder or softer in the compensation for initial, mid, and end positions. It is programmable so that a lack of load or more load than the model has set in it is right for your setup. This means less compensation for under or overshoot if you set it properly. To much in the low and it will oscillate. Too little in the low and it will be sluggish and take another small step to match the actual to commanded. Since you are using a throttle which will have very little load a servo that has an internal comparator expecting allot of load it may take a small step backwards to match the actual to commanded. It all happens in microseconds.

the bad-sanwa does not sell replacement gear sets but it may not matter to throttle control.

we know that some of the specs published dont mean anything. The CL is very fast but when servo mfgs publish specs you can bet they published them from a lab environment that enhances their product specs. What this means is that being able to adjust the internal servo compensations to match the response to the command makes it easier to account for the real world that doesnt exist in a lab.

Thanks for all the info and I very close on pulling the trigger on the Sanwa.

It appears that replacement gear sets for the Sanwa PGS-CL servo are available (though expensive):
https://www.mibosport.com/en/sanwa-p...servo-gear-set