R/C Tech Forums - View Single Post - SC10 4x4 Thread
Thread: SC10 4x4 Thread
View Single Post
Old 11-25-2011 | 10:30 AM
  #11453  
lodhammerdin's Avatar
lodhammerdin
Tech Master
iTrader: (77)
 
Joined: Jun 2010
Posts: 1,194
From: Northern Mexico (aka, El Paso, TX)
Default

Originally Posted by CraigMBA
I understand that you feel that way, but think back at what the AE team guys were running for power since they released the kit:

- 540 motors without a basket, and the biggest rotor available to cut down on the KV, then -
- Wild Cherry caught all kinds of flack a few months back when he said the AE guys were testing a drilled/pinned top shaft, a rumor that turned out to be true, then -
- The Ryans show up at the Reedy race with 550 motors with a basket that they had to buy from some third party on the outside, and they win their first major race.

Which begs the question - why the change? Obviously there is no problem since the AE guys aren't trying to fix it. Okay, wait, that doesn't work.

Why pin the shaft and give up the advantages of the decoupled slipper? Chris Jaroz contention notwithstanding, several AE drivers have been running pinned for some time (BK included, who always runs more motor than anybody else) so that doesn't work.

Was it availability of motors? No, because the 550's have been available for a long time, why not run them right off? So that doesn't work.

The simplest answer was the FT AE guys knew they had a problem with the slipper right off the bat, and the early solution was to motor down.

A better solution would be to use the clutch basket.

And an even better solution would be an all new slipper setup (spur, front and back plates) that increases the surface area on the slipper pad (read that, larger clutch), because the fact is this truck doesn't have enough slipper out of the box for the big KV motors guys are running to be competitive ASSUMING you want to use the slipper to slip and not fade like crazy if you let it slip at all, which is what I expect AE to introduce on the FT truck, IF they don't put it in the RTR before that.

If you have an alternate theory, I'd love to hear it.
I'm not saying that there is nothing wrong, I was just giving my personel experience with my truck so far. I do agree there is a problem with the slipper on higher bite tracks, which is why I got my clutch basket but still I do not need to be pinned.

Only other thing I have to add is this...

Why does everyone throw "BK" out there like they know him? I do, I've raced with him many, many times at comp. I have talked with him for hours about this truck and he does not run pinned, only a basket which I showed him the one on my truck (MTK basket) 2 days after I got it. And as far as motor goes, do you even know what he runs for motors? He doesnt run something way higher than anyone else. He runs a 10.5 in mod buggy and has no problems beating everyone at comp and comp has some dam good racers (sean bray (kyosho sponsered), charles hicks (TLR sponsered), casey peck FACTORY TLR sponsered), and tanner denny (Associated sponsered) just to name a few)
lodhammerdin is offline