The site is registered with Network Solutions, which is a notoriously horrible company to deal with. I have been sending them repeated messages over the past 3 weeks trying to get them to fix the problem, and even though a week ago they finally said they would do it, it's still not done.
I could pay to transfer the domain name to a different registrar, but I am not too keen on dumping any more money into this. The club already owes me close to a thousand dollars.