Cleanly solder and you can still sell one, may be for a few bucks less but that way YOU will clearly know you made the correct choice ... that will be the only way to determine in YOUR application which will suit your needs the best ... asking which will be the 'best' for you to keep with the info given is going to be a cr@pshoot at best, too many unknown factors here to make the call in YOUR 'real world' scenario ...

JMHO, as usual ...