While I agree there's about a gazillion threads on lipos in the web, I'm not against the idea, say 1 new thread per year on the topic that could be stickied in the forum for example since product offerings evolve all the time.

Also since most lipos are outsourced from China factories and relabeled, quality control seems often to be an issue overtime and what was true at one point(good or bad) might not always be true 2 years after in some cases.

Next any of the online reviews on commercial website, while they could be useful in many cases, they sometimes don't give the whole picture since in many cases you hear more from the small number of users with negative experience and less from people with positive ones which could potentially misleading for others. These reviews are for the most part initial impressions, not long term use.

Lastly, how many friendly fake reviews are there on the net with newer brands that seem to emerge every month or undue bashing for some other brands and all done by the same few people? whereas here at least members history can always be verified if you're not sure what to make of a given post on the topic.

Conclusion: if done well, I think such a thread could be very useful.

EDIT: Diana's post has vanished! lol