Originally Posted by
Bry195
Im guessing someone thought about rotor mass. im just convinced they had to assume it was going to be driving a system that had mass and friction limits. A small change in inertia is a massive difference in feel. Acceleration takes 2, 3, 4 times the continuous current capability of a motor so acceleration and deceleration is where all the physics are at.
Do you think the manufacturing process is held tight enough to keep the physics close enough? These rotors are probably somewhere around 30 gmcm^2. If you want punchy I would think you want 10:1 mismatch and closer to 30:1 for ultra glide smooth.
Boutique motor manufacturers put that much thought into their motor design (skewed winding slots, optimized winding patterns, skewed magnetization of the rotors, tuned air gaps, etc.), but the big brands don't. That level of optimization is not cost-effective. Unlike commodity products like washing machines or water pumps or HVAC blowers, which are manufactured by the tens of thousands and all held to the same specifications, RC cars are made in small numbers and every owner wants slightly different performance.
The big RC brands just buy motors in bulk from the same factories that make motors for all other types of small devices, with generic "good enough" specifications. Energy-efficiency is not a primary concern in RC, except in some especially-competitive racing niches. Most people just deal with laggy motors by using higher-voltage batteries to shove more amps through their motors. Even people who pay attention to torque curves and throttle response just tweak the settings in the ESC to get the motor to run the way they want, rather than hunting around for a motor perfectly-optimized for their needs. It's simply easier to deal with the concerns you're mentioning by adjusting software settings rather than replacing hardware, even though it's less energy-efficient.
Of course, this is a hobby, so if you want to track down the perfect 36mm-diameter motor for a car you're building, you can and should do so -- and then you should show-off the result of your hard work.