R/C Tech Forums - View Single Post - Lets talk about motors
View Single Post
Old 10-27-2018 | 08:30 PM
  #28  
Bry195
Tech Master
 
Joined: Jul 2018
Posts: 1,011
From: Florida
Default

Originally Posted by gubbs3
I really appreciate posts like this as they entice my curiosity. I work at a tech company in a non-technical role which is perfect for my lack of attention span. My ADD sym/asym research tells me that symmetrical motors work well at low rpm and disadvantage in cost. Both of these are barriers to entry in rc. For a given voltage and current, rpm increasing as load decreases is a desirable quality which aids driveability.

Eddy currents and "magnetic" aluminum. Our equipment uses this principle to enhance accuracy. A really cool experiment to see how it works is to drop a magnet down an aluminum tube. Since aluminum is NOT magnetic, it won't stick to the side. It IS however conductive. Just like passing a magnet past a copper coil which creates electricity, the magnet falling through the tube acts like a coil creating a current and therefore, a magnetic field. The field attempts to hold the magnet in place which slows the falling magnet to a speed limited by the efficiency of the tube's conductivity. It's a bit trippy.

And on AL screws... The benefit is that they do not have a static effect on the magnetic field like steel. Since steel is also conductive they have both a static and dynamic effect on the field, albiet less dynamic since it's less conductive than AL. The truth is in the numbers though. Motors turn more rpm with non-magnetic hardware. The hall sensor accuracy (which we measure in asymmetry) also increases with non-magnetic hardware. Stainless or TI would be better than AL. Find me a non-magnetic and non-conductive screw and I'll pay big dollars for them.
Im intrigued by your comments and stainless and TI make sense.

I built a Dyno from an old brushless motor. I removed the stator and replaced it with a piece of aluminum conduit. It created a ton of resistance. In less than 20 seconds you couldnt touch the aluminum. Very cool stuff.Not sure why I wasted my time other than it took 5 minutes. im still considering wasting more time by just putting an aluminum disc on the output shaft of a brushless motor and varying the duty on an electromagnet.
Bry195 is offline