Originally Posted by
Bry195
is aluminum magnetic? look up some youtube videos and you will see some pretty interesting stuff that look like magic. an eddy current is created that puts the brakes on a magnet moving over aluminum. it doesnt repel or attract. I always wondered why people paid money for aluminum bolts for aluminum bolts in the motor can.
I really appreciate posts like this as they entice my curiosity. I work at a tech company in a non-technical role which is perfect for my lack of attention span. My ADD sym/asym research tells me that symmetrical motors work well at low rpm and disadvantage in cost. Both of these are barriers to entry in rc. For a given voltage and current, rpm increasing as load decreases is a desirable quality which aids driveability.
Eddy currents and "magnetic" aluminum. Our equipment uses this principle to enhance accuracy. A really cool experiment to see how it works is to drop a magnet down an aluminum tube. Since aluminum is NOT magnetic, it won't stick to the side. It IS however conductive. Just like passing a magnet past a copper coil which creates electricity, the magnet falling through the tube acts like a coil creating a current and therefore, a magnetic field. The field attempts to hold the magnet in place which slows the falling magnet to a speed limited by the efficiency of the tube's conductivity. It's a bit trippy.
And on AL screws... The benefit is that they do not have a static effect on the magnetic field like steel. Since steel is also conductive they have both a static and dynamic effect on the field, albiet less dynamic since it's less conductive than AL. The truth is in the numbers though. Motors turn more rpm with non-magnetic hardware. The hall sensor accuracy (which we measure in asymmetry) also increases with non-magnetic hardware. Stainless or TI would be better than AL. Find me a non-magnetic and non-conductive screw and I'll pay big dollars for them.