Old 11-05-2012, 11:07 AM
Tech Elite
iTrader: (244)
2canSAM's Avatar
Join Date: Mar 2002
Location: RIP Frosty, Best Dog Ever
Posts: 2,641
Trader Rating: 244 (100%+)

Originally Posted by MrgGoo View Post
Bad feedback will not do this situation justice. He has agreed to taking a poll tonight. Members voting on who they would side with and the loser buying the winner a brand new mini 8ight. I figure i could get our sponsor Amainhobbies to due the transaction at the end of the poll. How does that sound ? That seems like people would remember that. It would also let other members know that situations like this can be prevented if we act our age.
That sounds completely stupid to be honest. It seems to me you just want somebody to tell you it is OK that you have the car back and are keeping the money too. Well it is not. You are both wrong in this situation and 2 wrongs do not make a right. You sold the car as new, knowing it had damage as reflected in the pictures before the buyer got it. In my opinion the buyer should have returned the car right then and there and gotten a full refund plus return shipping. Now if the deal was struck that 40.00 dollars would be good for both parties and the buyer then came back wanting more, he was wrong. The car also should have been returned to you in the condition stated, but the fact that it was not does not justify you keeping the car and the money. If the buyer stole parts then that sucks and is wrong as well. Simple fact here is who is more convincing as the honest party. So far there are 2 strikes against you that can be proven, the undisclosed damage and you having both the car and the money. So again it comes to a case of he said/he said and I am pretty I know who my vote goes to on that. Leave feedback that is appropriate. If the buyer stole parts state that in the feedback. Otherwise let it go. I am not a moderator, and yes I tend to nose into things, but I see no further benefit, including a lame poll, to keep this going.
2canSAM is offline