Thanks for the tip Kevin. I realized that there is probably nothing wrong with my car. I looked at one of the setup sheets in the manual that used grey springs with ride height at 6mm in front and 6.5mm in the rear. I copied the exact same setup and also got 6-6.5. I gues the car is designed to ride high when you use the taller softer springs. I prefer to ride a 5mm or less, so I guess I'll have to find some shorter springs. I'm kinda bummed about that because I just bought a full set.
I'm not sure how long my shocks are, but I screwed the ball cups all the way in. Thanks for all the help guys!