R/C Tech Forums

R/C Tech Forums (https://www.rctech.net/forum/)
-   Radio and Electronics (https://www.rctech.net/forum/radio-electronics-137/)
-   -   Charging issues (https://www.rctech.net/forum/radio-electronics/792937-charging-issues.html)

Hoese37 02-14-2014 06:25 PM

They say 7.4 because they are sold as a 2S pack. The cells are made to be used as a single two piece battery.

Hoese37 02-14-2014 06:30 PM

Look here: http://www.smc-racing.net/index.php?...&product_id=69

They are sold as a 2S pack, Both marked as a 2S pack. Reading the description tells you they are 1S packs attached with a jumper wire.

Dave H 02-14-2014 06:32 PM


Originally Posted by spookie (Post 13009466)
You answered that one

Eta I would like to know, what controls the amount of charge each cell gets in a single pack. You have two cells in each pack, wired in parallel, right? You charge them in series as Dave explained already. with a two cell balance lead. My question is> Whats to keep one cell in the pack of two from receiving a bigger charge than the other? Since you are only monitoring the total pack.

The balance wire that goes to the jumper wire, between the two 1S bricks/saddles (along with the balance wires going to the main positive and main negative to make a standard 3 wire 2S balance connector) allows the charger to control the balance of each brick/saddle. (Picture in post #8)

Within each brick/saddle, the cells are connected in parallel, this parallel connection ensures balance between the individual cells within each brick.

Odin544 02-14-2014 06:42 PM

Its pretty simple. If both halfs of the saddle have a separate balance port then it's 2 individual 2 cells. Which its not. Thats not how 2s saddles are produced. If each individual half of the saddle pack does not have a separate balance port then they are 2 individual 1s. Which is how 2s saddle packs are made.

OP I'd pay attention to Dave H. Just my .02

spookie 02-15-2014 06:19 AM

Ok I get it. Some may think I'm arguing for the sake of arguing, but that's not so. My concern was with two gel sacks of chemical in one battery, being able to monitor charge on both sacks, not battery packs, but the two sacks of gel inside.

Yes, when two battery packs are charged in series they balance, but you still have a single balance lead on each pack, combining on both to make 2S leads, which has 2 sacks of gel inside on each.

Just saying they charge because their saddle packs doesn't really answer the questions. Most people probably don't even think about stuff like this, because they are told to charge it a certain way and it just works, and that's fine with them. I guess I want to understand the process a little deeper than the average joe.

Hoese37 02-15-2014 06:54 AM

Youre clearly not understanding how current flow works between parallel and series connections.

Dave H 02-15-2014 06:58 AM

1 Attachment(s)
Each of the cases/bricks in the saddle pack has 2 balance wires, there are 3 balance wires on a 2S balance connector. A wiring diagram is attached for reference.

Assuming a 2S2P saddle pack for the moment, the left case has 2 cells directly connected, with a balance wire to each end/polarity. Same for the right case. The middle balance wire is shared, and is part of the series jumper wire between the 2 cases that make up the saddle pack. The end balance wires are essentially connected the same as the main negative and positive large charge/discharge leads. Thus the charger can see the voltage of each case, across the respective pairs of balance wires, and control it.


Of subject a bit, but a significant portion of the standard 1/10 scale 2S packs are 2S2P and wired the same way, just all inside of one case.

ThePanda 02-15-2014 10:51 AM

I think he is asking what keeps the seperate cells wired in parallel in each block of cells in balance. Maybe?

plumbhard 03-09-2014 07:14 PM

Gentleman - Firstly let me apologise for not replying as I actually forgot I posted but finally worked out how to search threads I entered - I did actually sort it out
The cells were not properly balanced & therefor one cell was much lower than the other causing an error with the charger
Took it to local RC shop & they boosted the charge to recover cells to an appropriate level so that the charger recognized the battery
They are charged together as 1 battery with balanced lead - charged at 5.0A @ 7.4V (2s)
Have attached pictures to show so that it clears it all up
One pair was puffed so obviously not looked after
I appreciate all the advise & information

plumbhard 03-09-2014 07:20 PM

1 Attachment(s)

Originally Posted by plumbhard (Post 13081538)
Gentleman - Firstly let me apologise for not replying as I actually forgot I posted but finally worked out how to search threads I entered - I did actually sort it out
The cells were not properly balanced & therefor one cell was much lower than the other causing an error with the charger
Took it to local RC shop & they boosted the charge to recover cells to an appropriate level so that the charger recognized the battery
They are charged together as 1 battery with balanced lead - charged at 5.0A @ 7.4V (2s)
Have attached pictures to show so that it clears it all up
One pair was puffed so obviously not looked after
I appreciate all the advise & information

:blush:

plumbhard 03-09-2014 07:22 PM

1 Attachment(s)

Originally Posted by plumbhard (Post 13081538)
Gentleman - Firstly let me apologise for not replying as I actually forgot I posted but finally worked out how to search threads I entered - I did actually sort it out
The cells were not properly balanced & therefor one cell was much lower than the other causing an error with the charger
Took it to local RC shop & they boosted the charge to recover cells to an appropriate level so that the charger recognized the battery
They are charged together as 1 battery with balanced lead - charged at 5.0A @ 7.4V (2s)
Have attached pictures to show so that it clears it all up
One pair was puffed so obviously not looked after
I appreciate all the advise & information

:blush:

plumbhard 03-09-2014 07:26 PM


Originally Posted by Dave H (Post 13007533)
Here are a few images of 2S saddle pack wiring. Including one with the charger set as a 2S. The 1S bricks are are wired in series to create a 2S pack. Only one jumper wire between the pack to create the series connection.

If each brick was a 2S, the pack would need to be wired in parallel. Would require both positive and negative leads from the connector to each brick. If they were 2S bricks they would each need a place to put the small intermediate balance plug, like a standard 2S pack.


http://rcevilempire.com/wp-content/u.../sad7-copy.jpg

http://www.redrc.net/wp-content/uplo...anceAdap-2.jpg

http://upload.ecvv.com/upload/Produc...2161228247.JPG

You Sir are absolutely correct / spot on !

Dave H 03-09-2014 08:21 PM

Good to hear you've got it sorted, always like to know what happened with these trouble shooting threads.

I do think Spookie has a fair point about the labeling, not as clear as it could be. Not sure how to fix it though, labeling each saddle with 3.7V could be confusing too I suspect?

plumbhard 03-09-2014 08:57 PM


Originally Posted by Dave H (Post 13081809)
Good to hear you've got it sorted, always like to know what happened with these trouble shooting threads.

I do think Spookie has a fair point about the labeling, not as clear as it could be. Not sure how to fix it though, labeling each saddle with 3.7V could be confusing too I suspect?

TBH I think the labelling is quite sufficient - you need to treat them as one battery hence the loom wiring with them
From initially reading some thread I thought I had to double things - now that would have caused a whole other issue.
While one pack is puffy have purchased a saddle pack from Hobbie King & put the others aside for now :flaming: they still work fine & hold their charge just a little concerned on them & charging
I do put always in LIPO charging bag just to be safe

AGAIN much appreciated advise in this area - hope I didn't put the thread in the wrong place

drained714 07-24-2014 03:56 PM

SO i just got a new saddle block battery. And well it has 2positve tube holes A balance one in the middle and 2negative tube holes on the right. How do i charge this?
i have a set of wires for a saddle with a +/- and a jumper with the balance attached. and i also have another set with +/- and a separate balance tube. so whats up with extra holes? (++ . - -)
http://www.amain.com/product_info.ph...es-74V-5800mAh


All times are GMT -7. It is currently 07:01 PM.

Powered By: vBulletin v3.9.3.9 Patch Level 3
Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.