R/C Tech Forums

R/C Tech Forums (https://www.rctech.net/forum/)
-   Radio and Electronics (https://www.rctech.net/forum/radio-electronics-137/)
-   -   Is a discharge bank needed? (https://www.rctech.net/forum/radio-electronics/1086882-discharge-bank-needed.html)

Billy Kelly 07-04-2021 06:31 AM


Originally Posted by Roelof (Post 15802139)
Who is "we" or are you only talking for your self? I even did pinpoint him to any infomation, you did not gave any answer.....



I did make a discharger (topic can be found with some search) and did notice the power over the whole run did become more consistent.

I go off my lap times. If I see a drop off I’ll try a different battery. I’ve had a few go bad, but overall not discharging hasn’t been a issue

Roelof 07-04-2021 08:01 AM


Originally Posted by Alexv2024 (Post 15802143)
Leaving Lipos charged is the number one thing that hurts them tied with over discharging. I think race grade packs are far better at dealing with it, but you don't find serious racers leaving packs they care about fully charged from week to week. If you accurately track IR's you'll see them degrade by doing that. Puffing is extremely likely as well.

I'm pretty sure cheaper packs are far more failure prone to damage in general, just being lower quality cells.

Proper lipo care helps them last far longer than just leaving them at whatever charge state between runs. I'm at the point where I put my packs at storage voltage (3.8-3.85v) or post run do a balance "charge" where the charger just uses the balance circuitry to make both cells perfectly equal.

To bring a pack in "storage state", do you need a discharger but just a charger with a storage mode. For sure in current spec/stock racing you draw about half capacity in a run so with that they are in storage state already. I know I do with my F1. I have 4500 packs and run about 1800 to 2000mAh in a run, for me that is enough to put them away w/o any storage mode (dis)charging.

waitwhat 07-04-2021 08:51 AM

The extent to which a discharger (or any other "must have" go fast accessory) is NEEDED is directly proportional to the DRIVERS ABILITY to extract every bit of performance out of their equipment.

Yesterday when I went racing I won, set the fastest lap, and had a 98.6% consistency. I don't high current cycle my packs (I have an iCharger 406 and a resistor bank, so it isn't for a lack of equipment). I run the smallest batteries I can, so the slight performance gain I get from high current cycling isn't worth the shorter life span of the batteries. I already beat everyone handily by being a better driver. Yesterday also happened to be the first race on a new layout, so I know that I will still be able to go faster as I make some small setup changes and get more comfortable with the layout.

The vast majority of racers need more practice to go faster. A slightly smaller subset of the majority believe that they can buy their way to the front, and forgo the work it takes to learn to go faster.

the rc guy 07-04-2021 10:45 AM

track time is the only real benefit. but a discharger is a must

performula 07-04-2021 06:26 PM

This forum is to ask questions. The search, grammar (guilty and funny), matter of fact replies are unnecessary. People wonder why people aren’t drawn to the hobby. It’s this type stuff which discourages others. I contacted two tracks, they are far away, they both answered all my questions even got a phone number. They were probably annoyed too. Guess what? I’m buying another kit to go to their tracks. Come on we need to be community not another example of Facebook. If have enough energy to criticize or complain in typing - you could have already answered the question.

performula 07-04-2021 06:28 PM


Originally Posted by waitwhat;[url=tel:15802171
15802171[/url]]The extent to which a discharger (or any other "must have" go fast accessory) is NEEDED is directly proportional to the DRIVERS ABILITY to extract every bit of performance out of their equipment.

Yesterday when I went racing I won, set the fastest lap, and had a 98.6% consistency. I don't high current cycle my packs (I have an iCharger 406 and a resistor bank, so it isn't for a lack of equipment). I run the smallest batteries I can, so the slight performance gain I get from high current cycling isn't worth the shorter life span of the batteries. I already beat everyone handily by being a better driver. Yesterday also happened to be the first race on a new layout, so I know that I will still be able to go faster as I make some small setup changes and get more comfortable with the layout.

The vast majority of racers need more practice to go faster. A slightly smaller subset of the majority believe that they can buy their way to the front, and forgo the work it takes to learn to go faster.

Yeah that’s me so I don’t need a discharger then. 🤣

RRto997 07-04-2021 10:29 PM

I haven't raced for years and have just come back. But back in the day dischargers were used for two things, to have the batts have better punch and to have them last longer. I am just back to racing and it is one of the things I purchased along with new batts. With the price of batts, I realized it best to start off with as many batts that I could afford. I bought two different brands already and am looking at a few more. But I have noticed that the batts IR is kinda high. After a few cycles, the IR starts to go down. This is a good investment.

valk 07-05-2021 12:05 AM

i had a grumpy opinion on this but honestly.. meh.. if i was at a national or regional that i spend a fkton of money to go to id prob do everything possible to get the edge.. if i'm at home though.. racing my buddies in the club.. fk no.. i want my batteries to survive a little bit.. keep club racing as cheap as possible.. we can definitely notice the difference on track assuming similar skill level, but when there are other cars on the track it can evaporate those differences pretty fast... if you are racing heads up "which i feel is why we are all here" habits like that fade kinda quickly vs driver skill.
the nice thing about this hobby though is we are all individual racers who can all have a different opinion on how to get things done, and none of those opinions are really wrong.

RRto997 07-05-2021 12:21 AM


Originally Posted by valk (Post 15802352)
i think at the end of the day its going to come back to your competition level and your personal perspective.. if i was within spitting distance of even a regional championship id prob use every trick there was to get a last little bit of an edge.. "that time i used tire warmers to win the big barn shootout 2wd...everyone was like wtf... lol"
but i think for club racing.. im just there to have fun and get some laps in.. i know who i'm racing with and some of them use all this shit at club racing.. and some don't.. and its not super noticeable on track if skill levels are kinda similar. sure we say yea, that guys car is fast af... but if he hits stuff or gets bunged up in traffic it doesn't matter haha.
i dont know how to proceed further on this topic cause its just not something i care about haha. but maybe if i come down to cali and try to race my perspective would change.. i dunno.

Actually I do think that if you came down to SoCal, your opinion would change. When you're getting laps in, that usually means you're trying to get faster, to actually become a better driver, shaving a second or two off of your lap times, am I right? If the opportunity arose for you to prolong the life of your batteries while lowering the IR at the same time, would that not help you in trying to attain lower lap times? So track time is always a good thing, but also having a good chassis, electronics, batteries and more would also assist you immensely.

But I digress, come down to SoCal to race, often times a club race is a world class event.

Roelof 07-05-2021 12:31 AM


Originally Posted by performula (Post 15802296)
This forum is to ask questions. The search, grammar (guilty and funny), matter of fact replies are unnecessary.

About the search I do not agree. Afterr all it is his hobby and a hobby is something you love to do and want to gain knowledge about. Any own research is more helpfull to gain knowledge as you think and it shows that you want to put in some effort and time into your hobby, starting 10 topics in a few days with all kind of questions is not a sign of putting in some effort. And again, why would you ask a thing that is allready asked and aswered many times? I bet if there were 5 topics on top of this forum about this subject he still posted this question looking at the many topics he has started everywhere on this forum and some even dubble.

Regarding all his other questions it would be a better idea if the topicstarter does tell us what he is planning to do. He wants to know if his 2015 Xray is competive, if dischargers are needed, what batteries to fit in his transmitter, what setup station to use and if an antenna less receiver will work.

valk 07-05-2021 12:40 AM


Originally Posted by RRto997 (Post 15802356)
Actually I do think that if you came down to SoCal, your opinion would change. When you're getting laps in, that usually means you're trying to get faster, to actually become a better driver, shaving a second or two off of your lap times, am I right? If the opportunity arose for you to prolong the life of your batteries while lowering the IR at the same time, would that not help you in trying to attain lower lap times? So track time is always a good thing, but also having a good chassis, electronics, batteries and more would also assist you immensely.

But I digress, come down to SoCal to race, often times a club race is a world class event.

i wont disagree. though the hosting club gets the decide at the end of the day what tactics you can use.. in the wcics battery temp is measured and it isn't allowed higher than ambient.. some clubs care, some don't.. but one fire is all it takes for insurance to be revoked and we wouldn't have a place to race.. if its a business running a facilty its totally different but most clubs have to rent space which has different requirements ect. maybe i will play with this tactic.. outdoors. hard to have consistancy between runs for comparision though with tire prep and track condition between rounds ect.

Billy Kelly 07-05-2021 06:52 AM


Originally Posted by Roelof (Post 15802357)
About the search I do not agree. Afterr all it is his hobby and a hobby is something you love to do and want to gain knowledge about. Any own research is more helpfull to gain knowledge as you think and it shows that you want to put in some effort and time into your hobby, starting 10 topics in a few days with all kind of questions is not a sign of putting in some effort. And again, why would you ask a thing that is allready asked and aswered many times? I bet if there were 5 topics on top of this forum about this subject he still posted this question looking at the many topics he has started everywhere on this forum and some even dubble.

Regarding all his other questions it would be a better idea if the topicstarter does tell us what he is planning to do. He wants to know if his 2015 Xray is competive, if dischargers are needed, what batteries to fit in his transmitter, what setup station to use and if an antenna less receiver will work.

considering the low activity on the forums lately, having a few new threads isn’t terrible. It shows curiosity asking. Let’s be honest, the search feature here isn’t very good. I just tried a search here for “Battery discharging” this is what I got
https://cimg5.ibsrv.net/gimg/www.rct...ec12e3a079.png

Roelof 07-05-2021 08:28 AM

If you only search in this forum section to discharger or discharging you will be amazed what is found but still no direct answer, you still have to read.

RRto997 07-05-2021 08:35 AM


Originally Posted by valk (Post 15802358)
i wont disagree. though the hosting club gets the decide at the end of the day what tactics you can use.. in the wcics battery temp is measured and it isn't allowed higher than ambient.. some clubs care, some don't.. but one fire is all it takes for insurance to be revoked and we wouldn't have a place to race.. if its a business running a facilty its totally different but most clubs have to rent space which has different requirements ect. maybe i will play with this tactic.. outdoors. hard to have consistancy between runs for comparision though with tire prep and track condition between rounds ect.

How many clubs do not allow a discharger? I have never seen a discharger banned at any track here in California.

Roelof 07-05-2021 09:02 AM


Originally Posted by RRto997 (Post 15802435)
How many clubs do not allow a discharger? I have never seen a discharger banned at any track here in California.

Almost any charger has a discharger function so you can send anyone home? Even mij charger can discharge with 5A.
Over here we have a rule of no more than 20A discharging.


All times are GMT -7. It is currently 08:51 PM.

Powered By: vBulletin v3.9.3.9 Patch Level 3
Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.