![]() |
I toss mine in the trash and hope he makes it to the dump before she blows up..Ha!
|
Originally Posted by racer1812
(Post 15065739)
The salt water method is said to be a myth. The tabs on the cells will disintegrate before the pack voltage reaches zero.
That said, I've had success with the salt water bath. It discharged a cell from ~3V down to a few tenths of a volt in 4 weeks. |
Another place you could try is a scrap yard that specializes in e-scrap. You won't get paid for it but atleas it will end up in the hands of some poor Indian kid.
|
Originally Posted by alex4r
(Post 15067437)
I've read this too, my theory is that it probably used to be true on older packs but given the higher C ratings of today's batteries, I would imagine the tabs are much more robust. Of course, it's only a theory. :)
That said, I've had success with the salt water bath. It discharged a cell from ~3V down to a few tenths of a volt in 4 weeks. |
Originally Posted by Darkgenerals
(Post 15067765)
Another place you could try is a scrap yard that specializes in e-scrap. You won't get paid for it but atleas it will end up in the hands of some poor Indian kid.
|
Originally Posted by Kyosho Joe
(Post 15067842)
No reason not to put in trash can after they are discharged. Lithium Polymer is not toxic waste.
|
Agree,, just about every community has free drop off locations for toxic waste, paints, oils, thinners, batteries, misc electronics etc.. no reason to throw any of these things in the trash can other than laziness..
|
Originally Posted by Eric Bryant
(Post 15067323)
If you're draining the cells below 3V or so, make sure that you don't ever accidentally attempt to recharge the pack!
Honestly, once the cells are discharged to 3V or thereabouts, there is very little electrical energy left in the pack, and I'm unconvinced that it's necessary to drain it any further. You have to remember most packs are not single cell. A 3s or 4s pack would still have 9 - 12 volts of energy and I'm guessing wouldn't have any issue starting a fire. |
Originally Posted by gigaplex
(Post 15067845)
I hope you're joking. Recycling is about more than just dealing with toxic waste. Lithium and other materials in the batteries are in high demand.
It's the reason most recycling places wont pay you for your old lipo batteries. |
Originally Posted by gigaplex
(Post 15067845)
I hope you're joking. Recycling is about more than just dealing with toxic waste. Lithium and other materials in the batteries are in high demand.
BestBuy just gives tree huggers a place to feel good about themselves. In reality the "battery recycling" bin probably just gets emptied into the garbage dumpster with the rest of the trash at the end of the day:ha: Only battery I know of with enough value to recycle is the one likely in you car. That's because it's full of lead, and a lot of it..that's why they PAY you for it. Like I said before, toss it in the trash and hope the garbage truck turns the corner before you see smoke:lol::lol: |
Originally Posted by gigaplex
(Post 15067845)
I hope you're joking. Recycling is about more than just dealing with toxic waste. Lithium and other materials in the batteries are in high demand.
The story is somewhat different once we start talking about recycling millions of 50kWh packs from electric cars. |
Originally Posted by Eric Bryant
(Post 15069198)
There is a trivial amount of lithium carbonate in a hobby battery. The stuff is only worth about $3/lb, and you're talking about ounces at most in the typical pack.
The story is somewhat different once we start talking about recycling millions of 50kWh packs from electric cars. Not trying to put you on the spot, I work for a scrap yard and $3/lb materiel is getting into copper prices, and we don't deal in lithium batteries because the value is so small for the head ache they cause. |
Originally Posted by racer1812
(Post 15069124)
What other materials? And like Darkgenerals said, the amount of USED lithium in an R/C battery isn't anywhere near enough to make it worth the effort needed to get it out.
BestBuy just gives tree huggers a place to feel good about themselves. In reality the "battery recycling" bin probably just gets emptied into the garbage dumpster with the rest of the trash at the end of the day:ha: Only battery I know of with enough value to recycle is the one likely in you car. That's because it's full of lead, and a lot of it..that's why they PAY you for it. Like I said before, toss it in the trash and hope the garbage truck turns the corner before you see smoke:lol::lol: |
Originally Posted by Darkgenerals
(Post 15069212)
Is that $3/lb for new production?
Not trying to put you on the spot, I work for a scrap yard and $3/lb materiel is getting into copper prices, and we don't deal in lithium batteries because the value is so small for the head ache they cause. My main concern with scrap lithium batteries is the risk of fire, and once again, simply discharging them down to 0% SOC (<3V/cell) largely takes care of that concern. |
Originally Posted by Eric Bryant
(Post 15069679)
Yeah, that's for clean "virgin" material. It has some significant value, but there isn't much in a small battery. You've got maybe a couple dimes worth of the stuff in a hobby pack (or power tool, or cell phone), and so by the time you look at the cost of the recycling process, it's a fool's errand. The situation is totally different from the value contained in a scrap lead-acid battery. There also isn't the toxicity concern that one had with NiCad batteries (which we really didn't want going into landfills).
My main concern with scrap lithium batteries is the risk of fire, and once again, simply discharging them down to 0% SOC (<3V/cell) largely takes care of that concern. |
| All times are GMT -7. It is currently 04:32 PM. |
Powered By: vBulletin v3.9.3.9 Patch Level 3
Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.