R/C Tech Forums

R/C Tech Forums (https://www.rctech.net/forum/)
-   Nitro Off-Road (https://www.rctech.net/forum/nitro-off-road-130/)
-   -   21-4C vs P5XLT (https://www.rctech.net/forum/nitro-off-road/343407-21-4c-vs-p5xlt.html)

awdcameolsx 11-10-2009 05:50 PM

21-4C vs P5XLT
 
I was doing some research and am torn between these 2 motors for my buggy and truggy. I have driven the +4 in a truggy before and it felt nice, but I have also heard alot of good about the P5. I like a nice smooth power and the 053 felt nice on the +4 but I think it may be a little too much for buggy. Would the P5 be a little better or should I just order 2 of the +4's and use a different pipe. I am just not experienced with nova motors because I almost always have exclusively used OS but with their every steady price increases I would rather shy away from them.

mblgjr 11-10-2009 06:19 PM

The P5XLT will be a 'stronger' version of the 4 basically.

The standard +4 and P5XLT shared the same crankshaft (15009).

The 4C has a 'new'; but calmer 15007 crank. Slightly more torque, smoother feeling overall.

4C w/ 41021/9901 for buggy

P5XLT w/ 41021/9853 for truggy if you want something a little stronger in truggy it will have you covered.

If you're running a lighter truck, like the Losi, the 4C with a 9901 or 9853 will haul it just fine.

awdcameolsx 11-11-2009 06:05 AM

So what one of the engines has better top end and what one is better on mileage?

houston 11-11-2009 08:45 AM


Originally Posted by awdcameolsx (Post 6591828)
So what one of the engines has better top end and what one is better on mileage?

The 5 port design has more power from the port design . The 4 port has great mileage due to its port design and great power due to its crankwork .

The two engines share similar cranks but the plus 4 has the 15009T crank which has timing increases and smoothed fuel exit area .

The plus 4c has a crank that has all the 15009T work plus a larger opening in the throat of the crank , it went from 9.5mm to 10mm and is smoothed out . Plus4C crank is part#15007T


If you want a really badass 5port get a p5x/xs/xl/xlt. They are all the same and put a 15007T crankshaft in the engine , trust me you will not be disappointed at all

htcurt 11-11-2009 09:06 AM


Originally Posted by houston (Post 6592358)
The 5 port design has more power from the port design . The 4 port has great mileage due to its port design and great power due to its crankwork .

The two engines share similar cranks but the plus 4 has the 15009T crank which has timing increases and smoothed fuel exit area .

The plus 4c has a crank that has all the 15009T work plus a larger opening in the throat of the crank , it went from 9.5mm to 10mm and is smoothed out . Plus4C crank is part#15007T


If you want a really badass 5port get a p5x/xs/xl/xlt. They are all the same and put a 15007T crankshaft in the engine , trust me you will not be disappointed at all



Would upgrading my P5 XLT crankshaft to the 15007T increase power as well as giving better fuel consumption???

houston 11-11-2009 09:11 AM


Originally Posted by htcurt (Post 6592435)
Would upgrading my P5 XLT crankshaft to the 15007T increase power as well as giving better fuel consumption???

Yes but at the price it is something not everybody will wanna do for sure

87.50$ for the 15007T cranks. And that's a very good price actually

I will switch the cranks out for 35$ if the engines are new . That is the cost difference in the cranks

awdcameolsx 11-11-2009 09:19 AM


Originally Posted by houston (Post 6592456)
Yes but at the price it is something not everybody will wanna do for sure

87.50$ for the 15007T cranks. And that's a very good price actually

I will switch the cranks out for 35$ if the engines are new . That is the cost difference in the cranks

:sneaky::sneaky: I think you will be hearing from me when the funds allow it.

htcurt 11-11-2009 09:46 AM


Originally Posted by houston (Post 6592456)
Yes but at the price it is something not everybody will wanna do for sure

87.50$ for the 15007T cranks. And that's a very good price actually

I will switch the cranks out for 35$ if the engines are new . That is the cost difference in the cranks

Sounds good, if only i lived a little closer though. im in u.k sadly:cry:

htcurt 11-11-2009 09:46 AM


Originally Posted by houston (Post 6592456)
Yes but at the price it is something not everybody will wanna do for sure

87.50$ for the 15007T cranks. And that's a very good price actually

I will switch the cranks out for 35$ if the engines are new . That is the cost difference in the cranks

Sounds good, if only i lived a little closer though. im in u.k sadly:cry:

mblgjr 11-11-2009 10:27 AM


Originally Posted by houston (Post 6592358)
The two engines share similar cranks but the plus 4 has the 15009T crank which has timing increases and smoothed fuel exit area .

I wish they would do the 'tuned' crank in the 5 and give it the newer carb body/needle setup from the 4's...

OfnaJoe 11-11-2009 11:38 AM


Originally Posted by houston (Post 6592456)
Yes but at the price it is something not everybody will wanna do for sure

87.50$ for the 15007T cranks. And that's a very good price actually

I will switch the cranks out for 35$ if the engines are new . That is the cost difference in the cranks

Now you tell me !!!

houston 11-11-2009 12:15 PM


Originally Posted by OfnaJoe (Post 6592990)
Now you tell me !!!

Yours is a houston tuned version and is just fine Joe. Get it yet ?

Lmk what you think of it when you get it broke in

OfnaJoe 11-11-2009 01:03 PM

Yes I know, I'm just giving you a hard time. And it will be next year when I get it broke in, it's a Christmas present. Just now starting to get the 21-5k broke in even after your R2R service, this thing is TIGHT, Thank God for a Mugen starter box!!

houston 11-11-2009 02:26 PM


Originally Posted by OfnaJoe (Post 6593290)
Yes I know, I'm just giving you a hard time. And it will be next year when I get it broke in, it's a Christmas present. Just now starting to get the 21-5k broke in even after your R2R service, this thing is TIGHT, Thank God for a Mugen starter box!!

preheat !!!! :nod:

OfnaJoe 11-11-2009 02:37 PM

I do I do.......gotta


All times are GMT -7. It is currently 01:57 PM.

Powered By: vBulletin v3.9.3.8
Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.