2013 USVTA Scale Nationals April 12 - 14
#138
Guys,
Give us a day or 2 so we can see what's what. Eric has been following this closely. I don't want anyone taking action just yet.
Stay tuned.
And please, lets not debate this here. There are other threads for that.
thanks
michael.
Give us a day or 2 so we can see what's what. Eric has been following this closely. I don't want anyone taking action just yet.
Stay tuned.
And please, lets not debate this here. There are other threads for that.
thanks
michael.
#140
Don't have an answer just yet. We had an event at our track today so Eric was pretty much focusing on that yesterday and today. He has been following events and we'll get something out soon.
#142
76 total entries so far, about 40 in VTA. Racer count also at about 40.
Word coming soon on the D3.5 mess.
michael.
Word coming soon on the D3.5 mess.
michael.
#144
Tech Elite
iTrader: (1)
Trinity D3.5
Regarding the use of the D3.5 for the 8th Annual USVTA Scale Nationals.
No decision like this is easy and not everyone will be happy.
The point of contention seems to be the size of wire used during approval inspection process and then subsequent production runs.
The spec states a maximum of 20 awg or .813mm. It does not state "whichever is the lesser" or stipulate it as a +.000/-.xxx tolerance,as I believe it was originally intended. Had the word "maximum" been after the .813mm dimension, it would be cut and dry.
The RC community was also notified on 10/15/12 that spot checks and a "new" approval process would be developed for brushless motors would be implemented, which we do not know the process, as the approval form has been removed from ROAR's website.
We do not know what or how the wire was checked up to the announcement from ROAR, nor does it matter.We also do not know what the minimum inductance/impedence value for a mfg motor should be, which is also part of it's specs. The approval process has changed and all motors should be re-evaluated.
The as originally submitted D3.5 will be legal for this race as well as Novak's 3617R (which has never appeared on the approved list). The "maxzilla" version and D3.5/RevTech hybrids will not be legal.
If you feel, you have to have this motor to be competitive, I will make some arrangements to have, on hand a few "rental" motors for this event.
Eric
No decision like this is easy and not everyone will be happy.
The point of contention seems to be the size of wire used during approval inspection process and then subsequent production runs.
The spec states a maximum of 20 awg or .813mm. It does not state "whichever is the lesser" or stipulate it as a +.000/-.xxx tolerance,as I believe it was originally intended. Had the word "maximum" been after the .813mm dimension, it would be cut and dry.
The RC community was also notified on 10/15/12 that spot checks and a "new" approval process would be developed for brushless motors would be implemented, which we do not know the process, as the approval form has been removed from ROAR's website.
We do not know what or how the wire was checked up to the announcement from ROAR, nor does it matter.We also do not know what the minimum inductance/impedence value for a mfg motor should be, which is also part of it's specs. The approval process has changed and all motors should be re-evaluated.
The as originally submitted D3.5 will be legal for this race as well as Novak's 3617R (which has never appeared on the approved list). The "maxzilla" version and D3.5/RevTech hybrids will not be legal.
If you feel, you have to have this motor to be competitive, I will make some arrangements to have, on hand a few "rental" motors for this event.
Eric
#145
Regarding the use of the D3.5 for the 8th Annual USVTA Scale Nationals.
The as originally submitted D3.5 will be legal for this race as well as Novak's 3617R (which has never appeared on the approved list). The "maxzilla" version and D3.5/RevTech hybrids will not be legal.
Eric
The as originally submitted D3.5 will be legal for this race as well as Novak's 3617R (which has never appeared on the approved list). The "maxzilla" version and D3.5/RevTech hybrids will not be legal.
Eric
#147
Ah, Thanks ... both photos on the website show a purple rotor in each motor. And, I didn't read the description stating that the "Maxzilla" version has the HT rotor. my bad
Last edited by trytowin; 01-21-2013 at 08:33 AM. Reason: added info
#148
Ummm, this just dawned on me ... the rotor has nothing to do with the ruling.
#150
Tech Elite
iTrader: (1)
Driver's List
We are at 50 people so far, that's 2/3 of our capacity for this event.
This will also be the first time a driver will come back to defend their belt.
USVTA
Paul Bailey
Sam Bailey
Bernie Beck
Paul Daily
Mitch Ferguson
Eric Gottsacker
Mike Hardin
David Hart
Jeff Hendrix
Jim Hungate
Battman
John Renkes
Adam Russell
Larry schoenbrod
Carl Seils
Richard Sitko
David Weir
AJ Wilusz
Bill Wilusz
Bob Davis
Ken Pepe
Keith Laymon
Kevin Kane
Brad Dale
Seth Arnold
Derrick Maxie
Natt
Dave Trac
Zack Wells
Alan Bachman
Nathan Thompson
Jim Oliva
John Ermer
Mike Larson
John Adams
Richard Devroeg
Rob King
Tim "ski"
Joe Kleinknight
Dickey Mahoney
Tony Kerpan
Bob Davis
Ken Pepe
Dan Cook
Justin Zorc*
USGT
Paul Bailey
Sam Bailey
Paul Daily
Bernie Beck
Jeff Hendrix
Battman
Adam Russell
Larry Schoenbrod
David Weir
Kevin Kane
Brad Dale
Derrick Maxie
Zack Wells
Jim Oliva
Richard Devroeg
Rob King
Tim "ski"
Joe Kleinknight
Tony Kerpan
Ken Pepe*
Rich Murphy*
Dan Cook
RJ Whiteside
Justin Lyons
M-Chassis
Mitch Ferguson
Larry Schoenbrod
Carl Seils
Bill Wilusz
AJ Wilusz
13.5 1/12
Battman
Justin Zorc*
Seth Arnold
Mike Larson
John Adams
Fred Kellner*
17.5 Sedan
Dave Trac
Alan Bachman
Mike Larson
John Adams
Snowy
Rj Whiteside
Justin Lyons
Battman
Keith Laymon
Brad Dale
*= unconfirmed
This will also be the first time a driver will come back to defend their belt.
USVTA
Paul Bailey
Sam Bailey
Bernie Beck
Paul Daily
Mitch Ferguson
Eric Gottsacker
Mike Hardin
David Hart
Jeff Hendrix
Jim Hungate
Battman
John Renkes
Adam Russell
Larry schoenbrod
Carl Seils
Richard Sitko
David Weir
AJ Wilusz
Bill Wilusz
Bob Davis
Ken Pepe
Keith Laymon
Kevin Kane
Brad Dale
Seth Arnold
Derrick Maxie
Natt
Dave Trac
Zack Wells
Alan Bachman
Nathan Thompson
Jim Oliva
John Ermer
Mike Larson
John Adams
Richard Devroeg
Rob King
Tim "ski"
Joe Kleinknight
Dickey Mahoney
Tony Kerpan
Bob Davis
Ken Pepe
Dan Cook
Justin Zorc*
USGT
Paul Bailey
Sam Bailey
Paul Daily
Bernie Beck
Jeff Hendrix
Battman
Adam Russell
Larry Schoenbrod
David Weir
Kevin Kane
Brad Dale
Derrick Maxie
Zack Wells
Jim Oliva
Richard Devroeg
Rob King
Tim "ski"
Joe Kleinknight
Tony Kerpan
Ken Pepe*
Rich Murphy*
Dan Cook
RJ Whiteside
Justin Lyons
M-Chassis
Mitch Ferguson
Larry Schoenbrod
Carl Seils
Bill Wilusz
AJ Wilusz
13.5 1/12
Battman
Justin Zorc*
Seth Arnold
Mike Larson
John Adams
Fred Kellner*
17.5 Sedan
Dave Trac
Alan Bachman
Mike Larson
John Adams
Snowy
Rj Whiteside
Justin Lyons
Battman
Keith Laymon
Brad Dale
*= unconfirmed
Last edited by ercwhtsd; 01-21-2013 at 02:16 PM.