ZAPPED MOTORS:PROS AND CONS 101
#1
ZAPPED MOTORS:PROS AND CONS 101
HI GUYS...I RECENTLY BOUGHT A MO3-R AND LOVE IT TO DEATH. MY SETUP IS GREAT BUT I JUST DONT HAVE ENOUGH MOTOR TO RUN WITH SOME OF THE GUYS THAT HAVE BEEN DOING THIS FOR A WHILE, I HAVE HEARD THINGS ABOUT A ZAPPED MOTOR AMONG OTHER BREAK IN TIPS. WHAT I NEED TO KNOW NOW IS WHO CAN ZAP A MOTOR FOR ME AND WHAT ARE THE PROS AND CONS OF RUNNING A ZAPPED MOTOR.
THANKS IN ADVANCE
THANKS IN ADVANCE
#2
R/C Tech Elite Member
iTrader: (10)
Zapping a motor is a bit of a misnomer. What you're actually zapping are the magnets. This requires that the motor by disassembled, and the motor can itself get's "zapped."
The problem there is that if you're running mini, you're running a spec class, using sealed motors. No modifications or alterations to the motor are allowed in this class.
If you're running with minis using non-sealed motors, then go for it, but don't expect huge improvement, unless your motor was tired in the first place.
Jim
The problem there is that if you're running mini, you're running a spec class, using sealed motors. No modifications or alterations to the motor are allowed in this class.
If you're running with minis using non-sealed motors, then go for it, but don't expect huge improvement, unless your motor was tired in the first place.
Jim
#3
HI GUYS...I RECENTLY BOUGHT A MO3-R AND LOVE IT TO DEATH. MY SETUP IS GREAT BUT I JUST DONT HAVE ENOUGH MOTOR TO RUN WITH SOME OF THE GUYS THAT HAVE BEEN DOING THIS FOR A WHILE, I HAVE HEARD THINGS ABOUT A ZAPPED MOTOR AMONG OTHER BREAK IN TIPS. WHAT I NEED TO KNOW NOW IS WHO CAN ZAP A MOTOR FOR ME AND WHAT ARE THE PROS AND CONS OF RUNNING A ZAPPED MOTOR.
THANKS IN ADVANCE
THANKS IN ADVANCE
#4
Tech Master
iTrader: (32)
HI GUYS...I RECENTLY BOUGHT A MO3-R AND LOVE IT TO DEATH. MY SETUP IS GREAT BUT I JUST DONT HAVE ENOUGH MOTOR TO RUN WITH SOME OF THE GUYS THAT HAVE BEEN DOING THIS FOR A WHILE, I HAVE HEARD THINGS ABOUT A ZAPPED MOTOR AMONG OTHER BREAK IN TIPS. WHAT I NEED TO KNOW NOW IS WHO CAN ZAP A MOTOR FOR ME AND WHAT ARE THE PROS AND CONS OF RUNNING A ZAPPED MOTOR.
THANKS IN ADVANCE
THANKS IN ADVANCE
#5
Once your brushed motor gets hot, the magnets tend to lose a little bit of their magnetism. Zapping the magnets can (in theory) restore some of the lost magnetism. It can make a tired motor feel almost as good as new.
Some of the faster guys around here will run brand new motors for 5 or 10 minutes out of the car with no load on them at 5 volts specifically to "heat cycle" them. They then zap them to restore the lost magnetism.
Contrary to what was posted above, it won't shorten the life of your motor. They get zapped as a bare can, with the armature, endbell, and brushes removed.
However, if someone that doesn't know what they are doing zaps them incorrectly, it can actually *weaken* the magnets. Think of the magnet used to magnetize screwdriver tips. You can also use it to remove the magnetism.
Some of the faster guys around here will run brand new motors for 5 or 10 minutes out of the car with no load on them at 5 volts specifically to "heat cycle" them. They then zap them to restore the lost magnetism.
Contrary to what was posted above, it won't shorten the life of your motor. They get zapped as a bare can, with the armature, endbell, and brushes removed.
However, if someone that doesn't know what they are doing zaps them incorrectly, it can actually *weaken* the magnets. Think of the magnet used to magnetize screwdriver tips. You can also use it to remove the magnetism.
#8
who in the hell still runs brushed motors?
my gawd man it's 2008 buy a brushless system asap!
my gawd man it's 2008 buy a brushless system asap!
#9
#10
CCH1978:
Greetings and welcome to the world of "TCS race legal Minis". Most of the faster Minis in Memphis use either a Sid prepared motor or a "Doc" prepared silver can motor. If you like to try one, see me at the next MSRA electric race at Hobbytown (I'm the one with the red #3 Mini). I'll let you try a "Doc" prepared Red Dot motor.
From my dyno I show an increase of about 3-4,000 rpm with a prepared zapped motor. I have been using the same motor for about 4 months now without a decrease in performance.
And this is not an illegal mod as the motor is not taken apart.
PM me if you need more info.
Greetings and welcome to the world of "TCS race legal Minis". Most of the faster Minis in Memphis use either a Sid prepared motor or a "Doc" prepared silver can motor. If you like to try one, see me at the next MSRA electric race at Hobbytown (I'm the one with the red #3 Mini). I'll let you try a "Doc" prepared Red Dot motor.
From my dyno I show an increase of about 3-4,000 rpm with a prepared zapped motor. I have been using the same motor for about 4 months now without a decrease in performance.
And this is not an illegal mod as the motor is not taken apart.
PM me if you need more info.
Last edited by Three; 08-07-2008 at 09:45 PM.
#11
Three,
can you give some more info on how you prepare these silver-can motors?
I would like to try this myself.
Thx
can you give some more info on how you prepare these silver-can motors?
I would like to try this myself.
Thx
#12
I don't prepare my motors (I'm too lazy). I just know the results.
The person who does my silver can motors uses the name rccardr on RCTech. You can usually find him on the Tamiya mini cooper thread. He could explain the process much better than me.
The person who does my silver can motors uses the name rccardr on RCTech. You can usually find him on the Tamiya mini cooper thread. He could explain the process much better than me.
#13
Just to confirm what a few others have stated.
With the right kind of zapper you can zap a sealed motor without tearing it apart.
Zapping should not shorten a motors life. In fact stronger magnets often run cooler.
With the right kind of zapper you can zap a sealed motor without tearing it apart.
Zapping should not shorten a motors life. In fact stronger magnets often run cooler.
#14
Tech Elite
iTrader: (8)
Join Date: Aug 2003
Location: The Secret Underground Laboratory
Posts: 2,353
Trader Rating: 8 (100%+)
Tuned motors (no matter how they are messed with) run faster, and faster means hotter unless you mess with the gearing which, on a Mini is pretty limited.
Although some of my customers prefer to run an 18 tooth pinion with their Red Dot motors for a little more punch out of the corners without losing any speed on the straights, we see very little temperature differential with the 18 tooth. And heat is indeed the enemy, because when the ceramic magnets in a Johnson motor get really hot, they lose some of their ability to hold magnetic force (gauss) and no amount of magnet enhancement technology will ever bring that back.
Best thing to do with a tuned motor in a Mini is to run a Novak 5 volt fan right off of the battery at 7.2 volts. It pushes a lot of air, lasts a season or two, and we just Shoo Goo 'em to the chassis right above the motor.
Although some of my customers prefer to run an 18 tooth pinion with their Red Dot motors for a little more punch out of the corners without losing any speed on the straights, we see very little temperature differential with the 18 tooth. And heat is indeed the enemy, because when the ceramic magnets in a Johnson motor get really hot, they lose some of their ability to hold magnetic force (gauss) and no amount of magnet enhancement technology will ever bring that back.
Best thing to do with a tuned motor in a Mini is to run a Novak 5 volt fan right off of the battery at 7.2 volts. It pushes a lot of air, lasts a season or two, and we just Shoo Goo 'em to the chassis right above the motor.