Novak 13mm Sintered Rotor
#76
The Evicerator
That is the 5 cell gear ratio!
8.5 for the 3.5 and 7.6 for the 4.5.
With 6 cells with the new rotor I would run around 9.1 and 8.5 respectively
8.5 for the 3.5 and 7.6 for the 4.5.
With 6 cells with the new rotor I would run around 9.1 and 8.5 respectively
#77
#79
cant wait for mine. $30 is farking cheap
#80
Tech Adept
iTrader: (1)
4.5 bonded
Any company that is coming out with bonded rotors in the more aggressive BL motors are asking for problems. Novak realized this and went sintered....FAAAST!. For the milder winds, bonded really isnt an issue. When you get in the 4.5 and 3.5 range, those rotors shatter like they were hit with a hammer.
#81
Tech Master
iTrader: (6)
hey just to let to let you me and my cousin run an endro-car every year with a 4.5 Novak, we ran a system for 2 years with the bonded rotor (we just replaced it with a sintered system). every weekend a 24 minute race and one weekend a 48 min race. for 2 year never had a problem. reason for replacing the system was he wanted a 4.5 for onroad truck racing( we have skateboard jumps, thus no landing, very very fun.)
#84
Company Representative
#85
#86
Tech Regular
Back when I raced with brushed motors in spec classes I would usually buy a motor (maybe two) for the season, then a couple extra arms (at $15 a pop). I would also have to buy a seasons worth of brushes, motor springs and shims (which all add up in cost). Then spend hours tuning, cutting, shimming, etc. Swaping out arms because I didn't want to lug around my comm lathe with me to the track everyweek. Then, don't forget about the comm lubes. The next season, I would have to buy all that stuff again. It was a pretty large expense.
Now, with brushless I have one motor and that's it. I haven't even taken it out of my car since I've put it in there. It's worked flawless now for at least 50 runs. I haven't had to spend any time tuning, truing, or shiming. All that time that was spent working on the motor can now be spent on the track, or on tuning the car itself. So, if I have to spend $30 a season on a new, improved rotor (then install and forget about it) to stay competitive... that's nothing compared to the time and money spent on a brushed system.
Even the initial cost of a competitive brushed system and all the required accesories to keep it running at peak performance is more expensive than the brushless counterpart.
I think the brushed motor builders/tuners hate brushless motors because they can't make money off of them. Eventually they will be out of business because the brushed demand will decrease to the point where there just isn't enough money flowing in. This is very unfortunate, but it's also evolution. If you can't find away to stay in the game, then you will become extinct.
-Frank
Now, with brushless I have one motor and that's it. I haven't even taken it out of my car since I've put it in there. It's worked flawless now for at least 50 runs. I haven't had to spend any time tuning, truing, or shiming. All that time that was spent working on the motor can now be spent on the track, or on tuning the car itself. So, if I have to spend $30 a season on a new, improved rotor (then install and forget about it) to stay competitive... that's nothing compared to the time and money spent on a brushed system.
Even the initial cost of a competitive brushed system and all the required accesories to keep it running at peak performance is more expensive than the brushless counterpart.
I think the brushed motor builders/tuners hate brushless motors because they can't make money off of them. Eventually they will be out of business because the brushed demand will decrease to the point where there just isn't enough money flowing in. This is very unfortunate, but it's also evolution. If you can't find away to stay in the game, then you will become extinct.
-Frank
You make some very valid points and I would agree with the cost effectiveness of brushless over brushed. But you seriously underestimate the group of folks (me inlcuded) who took motor tuning as seriously as chassis setup and brushless utterly ruins a part of the racing experience for me. For my e-planes I love my lipos and brushless for run-time, maintenance and longevity of the parts. I just find it odd that a major part of electric racing is going the way of the dodo bird.
#87
Tech Master
iTrader: (6)
Frankw, you are spot on. People that enjoy breaking down, winding and tuning electric motors, thats cool. But fellas, get with it. Brushed motors stacked against BL is a losing proposition. Show the world an instance where you can run the piss out of a brushed motor for more than 3 races without maintennance and it still run at tip top shape? You cant. All of that tuning and maintennance for a 5 minute race is lethargic, period. BL can go for an ENDURO if geared right. Brushed doesnt measure.
#88
Tech Champion
iTrader: (7)
I started off the day liking the change to the 13mm rotor. But as the evening wore on I noticed I couldn't keep up with anyone. I'm not sure this was worth it for me. I didn't have time between rounds to put the 12.3mm back in to test. So I'll see when I get time to do a back to back.
Anyone else have comments on the 13mm?
Anyone else have comments on the 13mm?
#89
Tech Master
iTrader: (6)
I started off the day liking the change to the 13mm rotor. But as the evening wore on I noticed I couldn't keep up with anyone. I'm not sure this was worth it for me. I didn't have time between rounds to put the 12.3mm back in to test. So I'll see when I get time to do a back to back.
Anyone else have comments on the 13mm?
Anyone else have comments on the 13mm?
#90
i havent gotten my 13mm rotor yet, but i never liked my 12.3mm sinter. lacks lots of punch...
i have now gotten back to a bonded rotor. i seem to like it lots better. seems to have lots more punch.
only downside is the bonded rotor runs subtantially hotter. and therefore needs smaller pinion.
i think the sintered rotor would be suitable for longer open tracks, but bonded rotor for short tracks/offroad.
i have now gotten back to a bonded rotor. i seem to like it lots better. seems to have lots more punch.
only downside is the bonded rotor runs subtantially hotter. and therefore needs smaller pinion.
i think the sintered rotor would be suitable for longer open tracks, but bonded rotor for short tracks/offroad.