5 cell Stock for the ROAR Onroad Nat's?
#46
No need for Li-Po !!!?
By the end of summer a very large percentage of racer`s here in the states will have already switch to Li-Po ...
This fact alone should show that if you wish to create a new class , design it so most of the racer`s will race in the class..
Racer`s are not buying 5 cell pack`s or even ditching one cell off their 6 cell packs....
So
doubt that even the Europeans will stay 5 cell all that much longer ....
By the end of summer a very large percentage of racer`s here in the states will have already switch to Li-Po ...
This fact alone should show that if you wish to create a new class , design it so most of the racer`s will race in the class..
Racer`s are not buying 5 cell pack`s or even ditching one cell off their 6 cell packs....
So
doubt that even the Europeans will stay 5 cell all that much longer ....
#47
Not one racer from the reedy race complained about 5 cell....... And they even were pushing the issue of getting a 5 cell mod class for the outdoor nats.
The fact remains.... the races are 5 minutes long.
Also what about 12th scale. 12th scale has gained more intrest in the past year and a half than anything in onroad. No one has lipo packs that are safe for 12th scale. So are you saying everyone will need to get lipos for touring and then run nimh packs for 12th scale ? I am sure most guys will want to stick to buying and running one type of cell(s) for the time being. Everyone knows lipo is the future of rc.... but it just isnt time for lipo to become the power source of electric rc.
There has to be a few things to happen.... for example to warrent going to lipo the time of the qualifiers and mains would have to be bumped up a substantial amount say from 5 minutes to say 10 minutes. More time on the track is great..... but then how many hours does that add to the nationals events? IIC and Snowbirds both allow a huge amount of driver to experience the ultimate in competition and away from the track fun ... are these races going to be a week long then? I dont think there is enough vacation time in a persons year to get all that time off. Another example is if they dont increase the time of the quals and mains why bother going to lipo right now. We already come off the track with more than enough power left in the cells to go a few minutes more ( 1 to 2 ) and if running a brushless we can already run 10 minutes strong.
I personally feel that 5 cell brushless might become the future ( next roar desicion time ) cause going 5 cell and running brushless in stock/19t/mod will allow for longer quals and mains if they go that route. But then within say 3 years lipo brushless . I just dont think it is time for lipo. But i am not arguing that it is or is not the future.
The fact remains.... the races are 5 minutes long.
Also what about 12th scale. 12th scale has gained more intrest in the past year and a half than anything in onroad. No one has lipo packs that are safe for 12th scale. So are you saying everyone will need to get lipos for touring and then run nimh packs for 12th scale ? I am sure most guys will want to stick to buying and running one type of cell(s) for the time being. Everyone knows lipo is the future of rc.... but it just isnt time for lipo to become the power source of electric rc.
There has to be a few things to happen.... for example to warrent going to lipo the time of the qualifiers and mains would have to be bumped up a substantial amount say from 5 minutes to say 10 minutes. More time on the track is great..... but then how many hours does that add to the nationals events? IIC and Snowbirds both allow a huge amount of driver to experience the ultimate in competition and away from the track fun ... are these races going to be a week long then? I dont think there is enough vacation time in a persons year to get all that time off. Another example is if they dont increase the time of the quals and mains why bother going to lipo right now. We already come off the track with more than enough power left in the cells to go a few minutes more ( 1 to 2 ) and if running a brushless we can already run 10 minutes strong.
I personally feel that 5 cell brushless might become the future ( next roar desicion time ) cause going 5 cell and running brushless in stock/19t/mod will allow for longer quals and mains if they go that route. But then within say 3 years lipo brushless . I just dont think it is time for lipo. But i am not arguing that it is or is not the future.
Last edited by wallstreet; 06-17-2007 at 08:12 AM.
#48
WHY THE Fruck is everything a damn Lipo vs nimh conquest.
I have been seeing these stupid arguments everwhere, some one please suspend these guys.
We know f-ing lipo is here and catching on already we all know this , but you stupid idiots are the one's geting everyone botherd about it because you turn everything into a damn lipo cruisade. Plus most of all the fast guys are already tested or testing for lipo. Which really doesnt matter because this is a thread about trying out 5 cells at a national where lipo is not allowed. Unless you have something to contribute about 5 cell which you dont SHUT THE HELL UP!
Sorry to all the innocent bystanders I have had enough of these guys, its the same crap all the time even when lipo isnt part of the picture..
Guys here in Florida have been running 5 cell brushless in mod since the begining of the year , and have not switched back to six cell. Cars run cooler and wear tires less. It seems to also made the class grow from 5 guys to 25. I say go ahead and try it the main benifit is that you'll carry more corner speed.
I have been seeing these stupid arguments everwhere, some one please suspend these guys.
We know f-ing lipo is here and catching on already we all know this , but you stupid idiots are the one's geting everyone botherd about it because you turn everything into a damn lipo cruisade. Plus most of all the fast guys are already tested or testing for lipo. Which really doesnt matter because this is a thread about trying out 5 cells at a national where lipo is not allowed. Unless you have something to contribute about 5 cell which you dont SHUT THE HELL UP!
Sorry to all the innocent bystanders I have had enough of these guys, its the same crap all the time even when lipo isnt part of the picture..
Guys here in Florida have been running 5 cell brushless in mod since the begining of the year , and have not switched back to six cell. Cars run cooler and wear tires less. It seems to also made the class grow from 5 guys to 25. I say go ahead and try it the main benifit is that you'll carry more corner speed.
#49
Tech Lord
iTrader: (32)
That said, I don't think it would be much different if I were running a new 4200 pack. The current generation of LiPo match up really well with 6 cell 4200's for club racing. It's actually really nice right now, since we can run them together without upsetting anybody, and give people choices. If the NiMH guys went to 5 cell, it could upset that balance and choice we currently have in the clubs. That would be a bad thing. Don't take away options. 5 cell takes away the option of LiPo and brushed motors in mod. There's nothing good about that.
#50
Super Moderator
iTrader: (239)
WHY THE Fruck is everything a damn Lipo vs nimh conquest.
I have been seeing these stupid arguments everwhere, some one please suspend these guys.
We know f-ing lipo is here and catching on already we all know this , but you stupid idiots are the one's geting everyone botherd about it because you turn everything into a damn lipo cruisade. Plus most of all the fast guys are already tested or testing for lipo. Which really doesnt matter because this is a thread about trying out 5 cells at a national where lipo is not allowed. Unless you have something to contribute about 5 cell which you dont SHUT THE HELL UP!
Sorry to all the innocent bystanders I have had enough of these guys, its the same crap all the time even when lipo isnt part of the picture..
Guys here in Florida have been running 5 cell brushless in mod here since the beging of the year all have not switched back to six cell. Cars run cooler and wear tires less. It seems to also make the class grow from 5 guys to 25. I say go ahead and try it the main benifit is that you'll carry more corner speed.
I have been seeing these stupid arguments everwhere, some one please suspend these guys.
We know f-ing lipo is here and catching on already we all know this , but you stupid idiots are the one's geting everyone botherd about it because you turn everything into a damn lipo cruisade. Plus most of all the fast guys are already tested or testing for lipo. Which really doesnt matter because this is a thread about trying out 5 cells at a national where lipo is not allowed. Unless you have something to contribute about 5 cell which you dont SHUT THE HELL UP!
Sorry to all the innocent bystanders I have had enough of these guys, its the same crap all the time even when lipo isnt part of the picture..
Guys here in Florida have been running 5 cell brushless in mod here since the beging of the year all have not switched back to six cell. Cars run cooler and wear tires less. It seems to also make the class grow from 5 guys to 25. I say go ahead and try it the main benifit is that you'll carry more corner speed.
#51
Tech Lord
iTrader: (32)
WHY THE Fruck is everything a damn Lipo vs nimh conquest.
I have been seeing these stupid arguments everwhere, some one please suspend these guys.
We know f-ing lipo is here and catching on already we all know this , but you stupid idiots are the one's geting everyone botherd about it because you turn everything into a damn lipo cruisade. Plus most of all the fast guys are already tested or testing for lipo. Which really doesnt matter because this is a thread about trying out 5 cells at a national where lipo is not allowed. Unless you have something to contribute about 5 cell which you dont SHUT THE HELL UP!
Sorry to all the innocent bystanders I have had enough of these guys, its the same crap all the time even when lipo isnt part of the picture..
Guys here in Florida have been running 5 cell brushless in mod since the begining of the year , and have not switched back to six cell. Cars run cooler and wear tires less. It seems to also made the class grow from 5 guys to 25. I say go ahead and try it the main benifit is that you'll carry more corner speed.
I have been seeing these stupid arguments everwhere, some one please suspend these guys.
We know f-ing lipo is here and catching on already we all know this , but you stupid idiots are the one's geting everyone botherd about it because you turn everything into a damn lipo cruisade. Plus most of all the fast guys are already tested or testing for lipo. Which really doesnt matter because this is a thread about trying out 5 cells at a national where lipo is not allowed. Unless you have something to contribute about 5 cell which you dont SHUT THE HELL UP!
Sorry to all the innocent bystanders I have had enough of these guys, its the same crap all the time even when lipo isnt part of the picture..
Guys here in Florida have been running 5 cell brushless in mod since the begining of the year , and have not switched back to six cell. Cars run cooler and wear tires less. It seems to also made the class grow from 5 guys to 25. I say go ahead and try it the main benifit is that you'll carry more corner speed.
Your little temper tantrum isn't going to solve anything. It's nice to know people here would be happy to censor opinions they don't agree with, though.
#56
Your opinions should be in threads they directly relate to. This thread is about 5 cell not lipo...what don't you understand about that???
#57
Tech Lord
iTrader: (32)
There, I talked about 5 cell. And, lo, I said exactly the same thing as before, in fewer words, without mentioning the other options by name, and now it fits in completely with the thread police guidelines. See what I did there?
#58
Super Moderator
iTrader: (239)
5 cell is a bad idea. It takes away several options and solves nothing. It causes more problems than it supposedly fixes.
There, I talked about 5 cell. And, lo, I said exactly the same thing as before, in fewer words, without mentioning the other options by name, and now it fits in completely with the thread police guidelines. See what I did there?
There, I talked about 5 cell. And, lo, I said exactly the same thing as before, in fewer words, without mentioning the other options by name, and now it fits in completely with the thread police guidelines. See what I did there?