4 amps will be fine. nimh batts can take quite a lot of amps.
If that is a new battery, it will also false peak a few times while "waking up".
simply discharge, let it cool, then recharge, and repeat. i'd do it maybe through 4 or 5 cycles since that charger doesn't have a readout.
First Bank & Trust Murphysboro
Alpha R/c Raceway